OTAGO YOUTH DROWNED.
DTJNEDIN, This day.
Robert Duncan O'Hara. aged 20, was accidentally drowned in the Molyneaux River at Paretai. The body has not been recovered. -Ashburton Guardian, 21/7/1927.
Particulars concerning the drowning of the young man Robert Duncan O’Hara in the Molyneux River at Paretai show that the deceased was one of a gang of four men engaged in constructing a groyne in the river near Mr Wm. Sutherland’s place, a few miles on the Balclutha side of the South Molyneux punt. The deceased had gone out to the end of the groyne (which extended for some considerable distance into the river), when Mr A. McFarlane, the contractor, and the other men heard a splash, and looking round saw O’Hara in the water. He came up once, and that was the last seen of him. The deceased was a son of Mr and Mrs John O’Hara, old settlers at Finegand. -Evening Star, 22/7/1927.
PARETAI DROWNING FATALITY.
(From Our Own Correspondent.)
BALCLUTHA, July 25.
So far no trace has been found of the body of the young man Robert Duncan O’Hara, who was drowned in the Molyneux at Paretai on Wednesday afternoon last. Dragging was at first resorted to in likely places, where the current might have carried the body, but now a is to be kept when it is considered likely that the body will come to the surface. Instances are being recalled where it has been weeks and even months before the remains of persons drowned in the big river have been recovered. In one instance two years actually elapsed, and then the remains with clothing sufficient for purposes of identification, were found lying on the strand on the Inchclutha side of the river near the mouth. -Otago Daily Times, 26/7/1927.
Mr D. Ewart, Paretai, one of the men working with the young man named Robert Duncan O’Hara when the latter was drowned by falling off a groyne on July 20, writes to say that the report of the fatality gave the impression that deceased had been very reckless and had lost his life in consequence. Mr D. McFarlane, who was in charge of the job, states that it was by a pure accident when engaged on his work that O’Hara lost his life. The deceased was a good, steady worker. -Otago Witness, 2/8/1927.
ACCIDENTS AND DEATHS.
BODY RECOVERED.
The superintendent of police has received word that the body of Robert Duncan O'Hara, who was drowned in the Molyneux River on July 23, was recovered yesterday at Port Molyneux. -Evening Star, 22/8/1927.
BODY FOUND ON BEACH.
(From Our Own Correspondent.)
BALCLUTHA, August 22.
The body of the young man, Robert Duncan O’Hara, aged 20, who was accidentally drowned off a groyne in course of construction at Pareta on July 20, over four weeks ago, was found yesterday (Sunday) afternoon. The body was discovered by a man named Tom Cunningham, lying on the sea beach between the mouth of the river and Kaka Point — about a mile and a-half from the mouth. An inquest was opened this afternoon at the courthouse, Balclutha, by Mr H. J. Dixon, S.M., coroner for the district.
John O’Hara, Finegand, father of the deceased, identified the remains as those of his son, whom he last saw alive on the night before the accident, July 19. He was then in his usual good health and spirits. Deceased had never suffered from heart disease, dizziness, or any other trouble. He had been examined for his life insurance over two years ago by a doctor, which was the only occasion that witness could remember a doctor's services being required for deceased in recent years. He had never complained about the work he was engaged on at the groyne being dangerous, nor had he made any complaint at all.
That was all the evidence taken, and the coroner adjourned the inquiry until next week, on a day to be fixed. -Otago Daily Times, 23/8/1927.
SOUTH OTAGO.
PARETAI DROWNING FATALITY.
THE INQUEST CONCLUDED.
(From Our Own Correspondent.)
BALCLUTHA, September 2.
The adjourned inquiry into the death of the young man, Robert Duncan O Hara, who was drowned by falling from a groyne at Paretai on July 20, was held before Mr H. J. Dixon, S.M., coroner for the district, in the Balclutha Courthouse to-day. Mr Bremner represented the relatives of the deceased, and Mr O. J. Cook (Dunedin), instructed by Messrs Irwin and Irwin, appeared on behalf of the General Accident Insurance Company. Constable Pearce conducted the inquiry on behalf of the police.
The first witness called was Andrew McFarlane, carpenter, of North Balclutha, who stated that on July 20 he was acting as foreman for the Otanomomo River and Drainage Board in the work of constructing a groyne at Paretai, which was intended to be a protection for the bank of the River Molyneux at that place. The deceased, Robert Duncan O’Hara, was employed there, and on the date in question they were on the groyne and engaged shifting a derrick to the last pile when the accident happened. All the men on the job — namely, deceased, Duncan McFarlane, Donald Ewart, and witness — were engaged in the work at the time, using crowbars. Deceased was on the extreme outside. He fell a distance of 7ft or 8ft. Witness saw him strike the water, and did not think he struck any projection in his descent. He saw him rise to the surface of the water a little distance down stream below the groyne. At the time there was a very strong current running. Witness and his son (Duncan McFarlane) ran to get the boat, which was tied to the pile nearest the bank. Ewart, in the meantime, got a stick with a drag on it, and went along the river bank to see what be could done to assist deceased. But deceased had disappeared before they got the boat launched. Witness’s son embarked in the boat. When it was certain that O’Hara had been drowned witness sent word to the police at Balclutha.
To Mr Bremner: No lifebuoy was kept on the job, and if there had been one it would have been of no more use than the boat in such an emergency, as the buoy would have to be kept on shore. The boat would be 27ft from the place where the accident occurred — in other words, the length of the groyne away. O Hara was levering with a crowbar when he apparentlv lost his balance.
To the Coroner: The boat was afloat. The water was fairly deep, being 13ft at the last pile at low water, and the tide made a difference of 3ft. He heard O'Hara call out when in the water, but could not tell what he said. The crowbar went with him when he fell into the water. He had said that he could swim, but witness had never seen him swimming. To have hung a lifebuoy on the derrick would have been very inconvenient. When deceased came up he stayed at the surface for a very short space, and merely splashed with his hands, and did not appear to make any effort to swim.
To Mr Cook: The planks on which deceased stood were dry that morning.
To Mr Bremner: The width of the planks would be 19in, formed of two planks joined together.
To the Coroner: Witness did not engage deceased for the work. He had been engaged by Mr W. Sutherland on behalf of the Otanomomo River Board. It was not a contract job. Deceased had gained experience of that class of work while on the job, having assisted driving 27 piles during the five weeks he was there.
Donald Morrison Ewart, farmer, Paretai, in his evidence stated that he was on the same side of the derrick as deceased, but nearer the shore. He saw deceased hit the water, but did not observe him before that. He came up once and cried out “Help, help!” twice, and then disappeared, going with the current. Witness took a stick, 15ft or 16ft long, with six prongs on the end, used for cleaning ditches, and went along the bank in the hope that O’Hara might come to the surface again. Witness saw deceased’s hat near the willows growing on the bank of the river, and that made him take the stick. The McFarlanes went for the boat, which was launched, and there was no delay in trying to rescue deceased. Deceased had told witness that he could swim; in fact, that he was a good swimmer.
The Coroner: Was there anything to prevent the boat being tied to the end of the groyne in place of being at the shore end? — There was too much current.
Witness, in answer to further questions by the coroner, said that very little time elapsed before the boat was launched. A rope ladder might have been useful for reaching the boat, if the latter had been tide to the outermost pile, but there was no rope ladder. The distance from where deceased fell to the shore was 27ft, but his hat seemed much nearer when witness saw it in the water.
Duncan McFarlane, employed on the groyne, corroborated the evidence of the previous witnesses as to what happened on the groyne, and added that he heard the deceased gasp as if he had lost his balance, and looking round, saw him falling into the water sideways, his right shoulder striking the water first. He came to the surface 15ft or 20ft away, and called out twice. Witness went for the boat, but by the time it was launched there was no sign of deceased. The current was running very swiftly, the tide being on the ebb. When he saw deceased in the water his hands were in front of his face, and he was splashing. There were willow branches jutting out into the river only a few yards from deceased, and if the latter could have swum at all he could have reached them. All that could be done with the appliances available was done promptly. A rope ladder would not have been of much use, in witness's opinion, and a lifebuoy would have been in the way.
Arthur Douglas Pearce, police constable stationed at Balclutha, said that, on August 21, from information received, he went to Port Molyneux and found the body of deceased lying on the beach a quarter of a mile from the mouth of the Molyneux River, and four miles from the scene of the accident. The general appearance of the body was compatible with death by drowning. It was not possible to see if there were any bruises on it.
The Coroner, in delivering his verdict, said there was no direct evidence as to how the deceased actually fed into the water, but probably he slipped. It was evident, that even if there had been a lifebouy available, it could not have been thrown in in time to save deceased. The verdict would be one of accidental drowning. -Otago Daily Times, 3/9/1927.
Balclutha Cemetery.