Search For Mystery Man In Otago Hill Country
(New Zealand Press Association)
DUNEDIN. November 6.
A Dunedin police party is searching the wild Silver Peaks area, 15 miles north-west of Dunedin, for a mysterious man who was encountered by trampers on Sunday.
The police do not discount the possibility that the man, who has been seen on several occasions in the last 18 months, may be Paul Keogh. a 33-year-old Mosgiel resident, who disappeared without trace on April 25, 1955.
The Mystery man was descending a track near a hut on Green Hill when he was seen on Sunday afternoon. He fled into the bush when he saw the party.
One of the trampers, Dr. R. L. Cotton, said the man seemed terrified and did not respond to his invitation to return and talk, then another member of the party spoke more sternly, the man something about looking for a dog and disappeared.
Dr. Cotton said the man was blackened as though he had been through a fire. He was heavily bearded and his hair was unkempt. The man's feet and legs were bare but his trousers may have been rolled up. He wore a piece of what looked like oiled silk in the form of a cape.
Dr. Cotton formed the opinion that the man was weak and emaciated.
Later, when the party looked back they saw him searching round a hut, presumably for food. Other parties have reported seeing a man in the district. Shooters on one occasion came to a hut to find it locked. The person inside would not open it and seemed reluctant to talk, although he inquired if it was a police party.
Difficult Task Yesterday afternoon, Sergeant J. D. Farquhar and Constables J. Barber. J. Orlowski, and D. Osborne went in from Waitati with a week’s supplies. They intended to borrow a pack horse from an outlying farm.
The task before the party is a difficult one. The country, all of it rugged and much of it bushed, runs to 3000ft and is infested with wild pigs and deer. It is popular with tramping parties from Dunedin.
There are numerous huts in the area for the use of trampers, shooters and musterers. It is conceivable that a person could live on the supplies cached at these huts by the various users, and that their disappearance would be put down to other visitors.
The police think the blackened appearance of the mystery man may be due to his living in a cave.
A finding that Keogh, a bricklayer, had apparently died from causes unknown was returned at an inquest on April 13, 1956. Evidence was given that he seemed ‘‘just his normal self” when he left his home in his car on Anzac Day, 1955. Some days later, his car was found in the Outram glen. The doors were shut and one window was down. -Press, 7/11/1957.
MYSTERY MAN IN OTAGO
Police Search Fails
(New Zealand Press Association) DUNEDIN, November 10.
No trace was found of the mystery man of the silver peaks by the police party, headed by Sergeant J. D. Farquhar, of the Central station, which returned yesterday after a four-day search. Sergeant Farquhar said the task of finding anybody who did not want to be found was almost impossible in the country where the search had been conducted.
The party had found a cave, which they thought had been used for shelter in the last few days. The remains of a fire could be seen and tussock and fern had been used for bedding. -Press, 11/11/1957.
Youths Capture Pig Believed To Be “Mystery Man’s” Pet
(New Zealand Press Association) DUNEDIN, March 24.
During the week-end, six youths from the Otago Boys’ High School, tramping in the Silver Peaks area, led to captivity the pig which is believed to have been the pet of the Silver Peaks “mystery man.”
The youths — J. Willis, B. Smith, K. Duncan, J. Church, R. Kershaw, and D. Fulton — were at the Jubilee hut when the pig appeared. It was quite tame and could be patted like a dog. When the youths left for the Mount John hut the pig followed them, and even after a night they were unable to shake it off. Finally it followed them down to the Silver Peaks Station, where it was led into a pen.
Landholders in the area believe that the man is still there, as they report the killing of a number of sheep, presumably for food, but they also think he may be ill as the pig has deserted him. No action is being taken by the police to renew the search of several months ago for the mystery man. -Press, 25/3/1958.
SEARCH FOR HERMIT
Settlers To Join Police
Settlers in the Silver Peaks area in the back country behind Whare Flat, Otago, are planning a manhunt to aid armed police to locate a hermit, “the mystery man of Silver Peaks,” whose smokeblackened cave was last week discovered by Mr H. I. Adams, of Silver Peaks homestead.
Mr Adams said in a telephone interview last evening: “He has cost us a lot of money, shooting sheep. We want to get rid of him.” He said that an armed police party of five, headed by Sergeant J. Farquhar, was out all last night watching the neighbourhood of the hermit’s cave.
Parties of settlers would join the police and intended to comb the area to find the hermit who had “been living in the cave for two years or more.”
The cave, which was partly bricked up with fragments of rock, was 2000 feet up rocky bluffs and commanded a wide sweep of the approaches. The cave had evidently been recently abandoned. When he found the cave, said Mr Adams, it contained three axes, three tomahawks, some primitive tin eating implements and a rifle with one round in it.
He said settlers considered that the hermit had taken his remaining stocks of ammunition and a second rifle with him when he left the cave. The hermit’s pet pig ambled into the Silver Peaks homestead yard last week.
There had been a fleeting glimpse of the hermit last year when he was reported to have been hairy, ragged and elusive, said Mr Adams.
Mr Adams said the hermit was dressed in tattered shorts and a ragged leather jacket. One ragged and heavily thumbed book was found in the cave. The title of the book was “This New World.”
Police consider the hermit may be a resident who disappeared in mysterious circumstances more than two years ago. Superintendent W. S. Brown, of Dunedin, said yesterday that the police did not contend that the hermit was a fugitive from the police. -Press, 1/4/1958.
SEARCH FOR HERMIT
Armed Party Eluded
The hermit, known in the Mosgiel district as the “mystery man of Silver Peaks," has shifted camp to other caves near his smokeblackened hide-out, and is still eluding farmers and armed police who combed the area for him throughout yesterday and last night.
Mr H. I. Adams, of Silver Peaks Station, where the hermit has had a mountain cave for more than two years, said last evening: "We had a big search today over a wide area, and finally found his belongings in another cave near his original one.
"Searching further, we found a terrific pile of burned bones in another nearby cave. He must have eaten a lot of our sheep during his stay.
“The police are continuing the search tonight. We are sure he is still in there. We could almost feel him watching us from the bluffs near the caves we were searching.”
Mr Adams said that near the mouth of the deserted original cave, settlers and police found two freshly-dressed legs of mutton thrown down on the grass, indicating that the hermit had recently been in the vicinity. -Press, 2/4/1958.
Police Persuade Hermit To Return To Dunedin
(New Zealand Press Association)! DUNEDIN, April 28.
The elusive hermit of Silver Peaks who for so long has evaded one search party after another has been found. He is Ross Adamson, a 31-year-old clerk, who disappeared into the rugged back country 20 miles from Dunedin more than three years ago.
Three young members of the Police Force — Constables J. Barber and A. Matheson and DetectiveConstable K. Aitken — came across Mr Adamson by chance today during a shooting trip to Whare Flat and persuaded him to accompany them back to Dunedin.
At the Central Police Station tonight Mr Adamson, frail and slight, had a wash and a good hot meal, for which he seemed grateful, a police officer said.
Constable Barber said that after shooting for about two hours they walked up a fire break on a saddle at Whare Flat. From a hut where the “hermit” was reported to have been seen six weeks ago smoke was coming.
Jokingly, the remark that “it might be the hermit” was passed, and they went up to the hut and knocked on the door. The occupant invited them in.
All three recognised Mr Adamson immediately, Constable Barber said, and, after talking with him for some time, they left the hut and discussed among themselves the best thing to do. They decided to go back and, when questioned, Mr Adamson admitted his identity.
Mr Adamson told the party he had watched more than one of the search parties on several occasions; often from a spot not far away from the searchers.
Asked how he had existed in the rugged country, he said he always had plenty of meat, although salt and cigarettes were the most difficult things to acquire. In his hut he had porridge, barley, curry, and small tinned goods. He was able to offer the three policemen a cup of tea, and he assured them that he was never short of matches. He said he often found money left by people passing through, and he had 24s 5d in his possession.
Although of extremely slight build, Mr Adamson was remarkably fit and looked quite healthy. He claimed that in the three years spent out in the open he had never been ill. -Press, 30/4/1958.
Remanded On Theft Charge
(New Zealand Press Association) DUNEDIN, April 30.
Ross Adamson, aged 34, was charged, before Mr J. D. Willis, S.M.. in the Dunedin Magistrate’s Court, with the theft between October, 1956, and December 29 1956, of a rifle, the property of Leslie Watson Gilmore. He was remanded in custody till May 7.
Slightly built, about 5ft 2in. clean-shaven, with a newly cut crop of sandy hair, Adamson appeared in white duck prison garb, partly covered by a heavy brown overcoat.
Detective Sergeant A. E. Leadley, applying for the remand, said it was almost certain there would be other charges. -Press, 1/5/1958.
“HERMIT” PLACED ON PROBATION
Thefts From Huts In Silver Peaks Area
(New Zealand Press Association) DUNEDIN, May 7.
A single man who for the past three years lived as a hermit in the Silver Peaks area near Waitati, Ross Adamson, aged 34, was sentenced to probation for two years on charges of theft when he appeared before Mr J. D. Willis. S.M.. in the Magistrate’s Court, today.
Adamson was charged with stealing a .303 rifle, valued at £12, the property of Leslie Watson Gilmour, at Double Hill, near Waitati, between October 1, 1956, and December 29, 1956. He was also charged with stealing a tent and carving knife, valued at £20 10s, the property of the Lands and Survey Department, at Silver Peaks between May 10 and May 13, 1957.
Detective-Sergeant K. T. F Samson said Adamson had been apprehended by the police on April 29, and had been in custody since. He had never previously been before the Court. The involved thefts from huts in the Silver Peaks area.
Mr A. P. McAlevey said Adamson was in sound physical and mental condition. Two physical defects, however, had left him with a marked inferiority complex. He had elected to live the life of a hermit because he had been unable to face up to a minor matter in civil proceedings which were being brought against him. He had suffered more punishment than any penalty the Court could enforce. Friends had “rallied round him” and he would certainly have both a home and a job. -Press, 8/5/1958.
Ross Adamson does not feature in New Zealand newspapers after his court appearance. A family grave in Dunedin's Andersons Bay Cemetery has on record the ashes burial of a man with the same name, who died in 2004 at the age of 81. His occupation is recorded as "retired clerk."