8/195 Private Henry William Bennett Edwards, (1/9/1883-6/7/1917). ""
Henry Edwards was a cheesemaker when he enlisted and was wounded on Gallipoli, his left leg being broken by a bullet. He was invalided to England later in 1915. He died of a kidney stone in 1917.
8/3905 Private Percival Clooney Geary, (22/6/1895-27/9/1916). "reported missing"
Percival Geary was working as a farmhand at Seaward Downs when he enlisted. He was with the 1st Battalion of the Otago Infantry Regiment when it went into action on the 27th of September at the Somme. They ran into a "withering blast of fire" from German positions. Two of the attacking companies suffered 100% casualties.
Percival was reported missing and his death was the verdict of a Court of Enquiry convened the following month.
24/526 Sergeant Malcolm McKenzie, (3/2/1895-7/6/1917). "a magnificent stamp"
Malcolm McKenzie was working as a carpenter when he enlisted. He was wounded in the ankle with shrapnel during the Battle of the Somme. Rejoining his unit after three days, he was soon made Sergeant when a previous Sergeant was wounded. He was killed in action shortly before the Battle of Messines.
SERGT. M. McKENZIE.
Another gallant New Zealander went West when Sergt, Malcolm McKenzie, son of Mr and Mrs R. McKenzie, of Bay road and formerly of Seaward Downs, fell in action. Mr McKenzie yesterday learned the sad tidings through a cable from his son Donald, also in France. The late Sergt. McKenzie was born in the Wyndham Valley 22 years ago and attended the Seaward Downs school. Prior to enlisting with his twin brother, Donald, in the Second Battalion of the Rifle Brigade he followed the carpentering trade. The fallen Southlander was a magnificent stamp of a young colonial and a splendid athlete. Two of his favourite branches were wrestling and bicycle racing, and as a speedy wheeler he was known all over the province. -Southland Times, 20/6/1917.
24/545 Rifleman Donald McKenzie, (3/2/1895-9/9/1917). "a fine stamp"
Killed in Action.
Coporal Donald McKenzie, who was killed on 9th. Sept., was a son of Mr and Mrs McKenzie, Bay Road, Invercargill, and was born at Waikawa twenty three years ago. His twin brother, Sergt. Malcolm McKenzie, was killed in the battle of Messines a few months ago. Both young men were of a fine stamp, physically and mentally. -Southern Cross, 29/9/1917.
34901 William Christie McCorkindale, (5/2/1888-10/5/1917). "appendicitis"
PRIVATE W. C. McCORKINDALE.
Private William Christie McCorkindale, who died on May 10 after an operation for appendicitis, was a son of Mr and Mrs John McCorkindale, of Seaward Downs. He was born and educated at Otakia, being 20 years of age at the time of his death. Private McCorkindale, who was a splendid rifle shot and an active member of the Henley National Reserve Rifle Club, besides a good all-round athlete, was farming and contracting when he enlisted in the Twentieth. -Southland Times, 18/5/1917.
61363 Private James Winton Noble, (6/2/1897-26/8/1918). "sleep on"
Sergeant Judson joined 2/Auckland with the Ninth Reinforcement, and served with them through the trench spell at Armentieres until he was badly wounded in the storming of the Switch Line on September 15th, 1916. He rejoined the Regiment after the Hun offensive, and was sent to the 1/Battalion, then holding the line in and about Hebuterne. His feat of winning the D.C.M., the M.M. and the V.C., all in the space of six weeks, is a record probably unequalled by any other British soldier.
The ground gained by the gallant sergeant and his companions was, however, not held, as the Division on the right retired, and, in consequence, the New Zealanders had also to draw back to avoid exposing their flank to attack. Later in the afternoon 1/Auckland were ordered to be ready to follow up in case of an enemy retirement after a short bombardment by the trench mortars. The enemy, however, showed no signs of retiring, and became exceedingly hostile, whereupon the Battalion received orders to "stand fast." Later, orders came to relieve 2/Wellington, and this move was carried out before the dawn of the 27th. -Official History of the Auckland Regiment.
PRIVATE J. W. NOBLE.
James Winton Noble enlisted in the 30th Reinforcements at the age of 21 years. On reaching the trenches he received wounds from which he died. Born at Millers Flat he received his education at Tisbury, and his mother, Mrs J. W. Noble, resides at Seaward Downs. Previous to enlistment he was in partnership with his brother, Alexander, in a dairy farm at Seaward Downs. -Southland Times, 9/9/1918.
James Noble served with the Auckland Regiment. He died from a gunshot wound to his spine.
FOR THE EMPIRE’S CAUSE.
NOBLE. — On August 26, 1918 (died of wounds), somewhere in France, Private .lames Winton Noble, 30th Reinforcements, youngest son of Mrs J. W. Noble, and the late James Winton Noble; aged 21 years. “Sleep on beloved until the day dawns.” -Southland Times, 9/9/1918.
8/3902 Private David Arthur Frew, (25/10/1894-11/6/1916). "casualties were inevitable"
When the 1st Battalion of the Regiment on June 7th, in relief of the 2nd Battalion of Auckland, entered into possession of L'Epinette Salient, which was our closest point to the enemy's line, it involved an increase of the front formerly held by the 1st Infantry Brigade of approximately 1,000 yards. Otago continued to hold the line there until June 21st, which represented an inordinately long spell in the trenches without relief. Raids on the right and left of the sector resulted in the Salient receiving the back-wash of the enemy's artillery retaliation, and casualties were inevitable. -Official History of the Otago Regiment.
An "inevitable" casualty of the retaliation was David Frew, who suffered a broken thigh and penetrating wound of the abdomen.
DEATHS.
FREW. — Died of wounds in France, on June 11th, in his 22nd year, David Arthur Frew, son of Mrs O. W. Frew, South Riverton. — Deeply regretted. For Christ and Humanity in the Empire's cause. -Western Star, 4/7/1916.
L. Ballantyne
There is no L Ballantyne connected to Seaward Downs in the "Online Cenotaph." It might have been 8/2838 Private Alexander Stuart Ballantyne (12/7/1893-13/7/1916) of the Otago Infantry, whose father lived in Edendale.
PRIVATE A. S. BALLANTYNE.
Private Alexander Stuart Ballantyne, whose death from wounds is reported, was the son of Mr and Mrs Peter Ballantyne, and was born at Edendale in 1893. After going through the primary school there he was a pupil of the Southland High School. He left with the 7th Reinforcements, and was employed on the railways, being stationed at Waimahaka when he enlisted. The late Private Ballantyne was born and bred on the Edendale estate, with which his father has been associated for close on a quarter of a century. -Southland Times, 27/7/1916.
23490 Corporal Duncan Alexander Horne, (19/7/1896-27/9/1916). "three shattered companies"
CARPENTERS AND JOINERS.
A SPLENDID RESPONSE.
The members of the Amalgamated Society of Carpenters and Joiners throughout the dominion have responded well to the call for men for the front, and it is worthy of mention that Mr Ivor Hazell, the dominion secretary of the Society, has no less than five sons at the front, four of whom are married men. The Invercargill branch of the Society has a membership of upwards of 400, and of these 46 have gone to the front or are in training at Trentham. Following are the names of the men who have volunteered: — George Kay, Chas. English, H. Huffadine, John Harper, T. Hartley, S. C. Calder, H. Nicholson, Jack Gough, James Walker, F. N. Margin, W. J, Whyte, Geo. Davidson, R. Buchanan, A. Lawton, E. Cook, Bert. Barton, Ernest Morris, W. A. Cook, Peter Fraser, Thos. H. Baty, Alex. Stirrat, Albert Smart, H. Broad, Geo. McKechnie, J. B. Sexton, E. Campbell, Chas. Sheed, C. H. Green, H. R. Goss, P. Carter, William Sheed, Hugh Winter, Fred. Murray, J. F. Malton, R. Crowther, Wm. Eunson, H. Donald, J. Doyle, J. O. Wilson, J. C. Kidder, Alf. Chatterton, Milton Green, Ewan Campbell, Stanley G. Compton, Wm. Laidlaw, and Duncan Horne.
Of those who have gone to the front the following have been killed: — R. Buchanan, Bert. Barton, and E. Campbell.
The following have been wounded; — Geo. Kay, W. A. Cook, Albert Smart, and C. H. Green.
The following have been invalided home; — Geo. McKechnie and Peter Fraser. -Southland Times, 15/2/1916.
Punctually to time and in good order the Battalion advanced to the attack, and with only a moderate number of casualties crossed the line of Factory Corner-Eaucourt L'Abbaye Road, From this stage the ground fell away abruptly and the attacking troops almost immediately came under a withering blast of fire from enemy rifles and machine guns posted along Gird Trench and Gird Support. The two leading Companies, 14th and 4th, valiantly endeavoured to press on against this hail of fire; but it was only a question of distance when they were literally swept away by it. Every officer and almost every man became a casualty. The 8th Company, (Duncan Horne's) following in rear, now advanced into the breach. With equal gallantry the endeavour to reach Gird Trench was renewed, only to find that the protecting wire in the low lying ground was uncut. Here the attack withered away, and the few survivors, the remnant of three shattered Companies, took refuge in the shell-holes. A few of our men, joining up with the 1st Battalion of Auckland on the right, had succeeded in reaching Gird Trench. -Official History of the Otago Regiment.
Corporal Duncan Alexander Horne, missing since February 27, is a son of Mr and Mrs A. Horne, of Morton Mains, at which place he completed his primary education. He is a native of Canterbury and an old boy of the Southland Technical College, and was in the employ of Mr Robert Blue, builder, of Invercargill, when he joined the 13th at the age of 20. Corporal Horne was a particularly fine shot and also a keen bandsman, serving under the Hibernian banner in local band circles. A brother, Sergeant R. H. Horne, went with the Main Body. -Evening Star, 1/11/1916.
FOR THE EMPIRE’S CAUSE.
HORNE. — Killed while in action in France, on September 27, 1916, Duncan Alexander Horne; dearly beloved second son of Mr and Mrs A. Horne, of Morton Mains; aged 21 years. “He died for his King and Country.” -Southland Times, 18/12/1916.
FOR THE EMPIRE’S CAUSE.
IN MEMORIAM.
HORNE. — In loving memory of Corporal Duncan Alexander Horne, Morton Mains (23490, 13th Reinforcements), killed in action in the Somme battle on September 27, 1916.
No one knows how much we miss him, Friends may think the wound is healed,
But they little know the sorrow Deep within our hearts concealed.
— Inserted by his loving father, mother, sister, and, brother. -Otago Daily Times, 29/9/1921.
68487 Private John Henry Sutherland, (12/5/1897-21/12/1918). "at rest"
PVT J. H. SUTHERLAND.
Private John Henry Sutherland, who was wounded on September 30th, is a son of Mr and Mrs W. Sutherland, of Seaward Downs. Private Sutherland, who left with the 37th Reinforcements, was previously engaged in farming. He was born at Brunswick, Kennington, 21 years ago, and educated at the Kennington school. He is a follower of all sports and is a very good gun and rifle shot. -Southland Times, 24/10/1918.
The Regiment accordingly remained comparatively inactive throughout the 27th; but on the morning of the 28th, a dull and stormy day, the two Battalions advanced to a point of rendezvous in the neighbourhood of Havrincourt Wood.
The New Zealand Division received orders to take over the front held by the 42nd Division and part of that held by the 5th Division, preparatory to a resumption of the general attack on the 29th. At 5.30 p.m. the two Battalions commenced their approach march, but the congested state of traffic on all roads forward, which preceded every attack, made progress slow and difficult. When the head of the 2nd Battalion reached Beaucamp, the enemy commenced to shell the village and roads, but fortunately the straffing was of brief duration. -Official History of the Otago Regiment.
John Sutherland's Army record contains, for the day that he was wounded, the note "GSW mult." - gunshot wounds, multiple. Those few letters contain a world of suffering for the month and a half between John's wounding and his death.
FOR THE EMPIRE’S CAUSE.
SUTHERLAND. — Died of wounds at 16th General Hospital, Le Treport, France, December 11, 1918, John Henry, the fourth son of Mr and Mrs William Sutherland, of Seaward Downs, in his 21st year. He was loved by all who knew him. At Rest. -Southland Times, 2/1/1919.
12597 L/corporal Hugh William Graham, (8/11/1895-30/3/1918). "improving the line"
LANCE-CORPL. H. W. GRAHAM.
Lance-corporal Hugh W. Graham, relented to have made the supreme sacrifice on March 30, was 22 years of age and a son of Mrs J. Graham, of Mataura Island. He was a native of Brighton, Otago, and received his education at Seaward Downs and the Southland Boys’ High School. Lance-corporal Graham was working on his mother’s farm at the Island up till his enlistment in the mounted section of the Eleventh Reinforcement. He was always a keen territorial, and was leader of the Boys’ Bible class and superintendent of the Sunday school at the Island. A brother, Trooper Jim Graham, of the Thirtieth Reinforcement, is also in Palestine, where he met Hugh a month before the latter’s death. -Southland Times, 10/4/1918.
At two o'clock on the afternoon of the 30th a minor operation was carried out by troops of the 1st Infantry Brigade, one Battalion of the 3rd Brigade co-operating, with a view to improving the line and gaining better observation. The objective aimed at was the line of the hedge from near the Serre Road on the right to a point about 1,000 yards to the left, which was also the line of the ridge overlooking La Signy Farm. The flanking Battalions were to conform to the movement. The main attack met with instant success; and it was only over a short stretch on the left that the enemy held his ground behind heavy machine gun fire. This pocket page 283was cleared on the following morning, and the new front, affording good observation over a wide stretch of country, was consolidated. The captures in this highly successful operation were 290 prisoners, five light minenwerfer guns, and the extraordinary total of 110 machine guns. Over 200 enemy dead were counted on the front attacked. Our casualties amounted to 43 killed and 100 wounded. -Official History of the Otago Regiment.
72265 Rifleman David Morton, (13/11/1895-31/10/1918). "thy will be done"
The NZ Rifle Brigade's Official History reports that, on the day of David Morton's death, a number of successful raids were carried out against German positions opposite them. No New Zealand casualties resulted so David's death might have been due to a sniper.
FOR THE EMPIRE’S CAUSE.
MORTON. — “Killed in action,’’ October 31, 1918, Pte. David Morton, dearly loved and only son of David and the late Elizabeth Morton, of Morton Mains; aged 22 years. “Thy will be done.” -Southland Times 2/12/1918.
FOR THE EMPIRE’S CAUSE.
IN MEMORIAM.
MORTON. — In loving memory of Rifleman David Morton, who was killed in action at Le Quesnoy, on October 31, 1918. “So loved; so mourned.’’ — Inserted by his loving father and sisters. -Southland Times, 31/10/1919.