Wednesday, 12 May 2021

Marion Steven Wilson White, MA, 1870-19/6/1897.


LOCAL AND GENERAL.

Girls are coming to the front, if we may judge from the junior scholarship and honours list of the New Zealand University. Of the 59 competitors who have been placed, 40 are boys and 19 girls. If this represents anything like the proportion of boys and girls who went up for examination, the girls seem to have numbered about 33 per cent.; and it is creditable to them that they should have carried off 50 per cent. of the scholarships — that is, four out of the eight open to the schools of the colony. Of the 19 girls who have a place on the honours list, seven are from the Otago Girls' High School; all the candidates who attempted the examination from this school having obtained good places on the list. Two girls from this school, Marion White and Catherine Moss, have won respectively the third and fifth scholarship; whilst Barbara Watt, another pupil of the school, stands third on the list of those who, failing to win scholarships, have yet obtained more than 1500 marks. The other Dunedin girls whose names appear in the houour list are Florence Muir, Elizabeth Gellatly, Jane Kinder, and Jane McNab. Marion White, the winner of the third scholarship, received her primary school education in the Milton District High School. At this school she obtained a board scholarship, which carried her on to the Otago Girls' High School, where she has studied for the last two years.   -Otago Witness, 3/2/1888.




Cromwell Argus, 21/2/1888.




We have received a copy of the first number of “The Otago University Review,” published by the students of the University. It is proposed to issue the Review monthly during the session. The principal article is one by Professor Salmond on “Plato and Academic Youth of Athens,” and a very capable criticism on “ Vanity Fair,” by Miss Marion S. W. White. The Review is a very creditable production.   -NZ Mail, 31/8/1888. 


UNIVERSITY INTELLIGENCE.  (excerpt)

The following Otago students have passed: — M. A (with honors). — Miss Marion White, first-class honors in mental science.  -Evening Star, 27/2/1892.

"Mental Science" is the term used at the time for the study of psychology.


LECTURES. 

A LECTURE on ‘Tennyson’s Women’ will be delivered by Miss MARION S. W. WHITE M.A., in St Paul’s Schoolroom on SATURDAY EVENING, August 6th, at 8 o’clock, with Tennyson’s Songs by Misses Tresseder, Muir, and Nellie Stevenson, Messrs Hopcraft, Salmond, Martin, and F. L. Jones. 

A. Wilson, Esq., M.A., in the chair. Tickets, 1s 6d, at Begg’s and Horsburgh's.  -Evening Star, 2/8/1892.


As showing the success which is attending the higher education of women in this community, it is worthy of being recorded that one of the successful students of the Otago University, Miss Marion S. W. White, M.A., delivered an able lecture, on the evening of the 6th inst., on "Tennyson's Women." The chair was occupied by Mr Alexander Wilson, M.A., rector of the Girls' High School, and there was a crowded attendance. Miss White's lecture was able and scholarly, and in her introductory remarks she dwelt with some force on the great change which during the present century had come over the relative social positions of the sexes. Miss White passed in review the women characters in "The Idylls of the King," "The Princess," "Gareth and Lynette," and the poet laureate's other well-known works, and deeply interested her audience.  -Otago Daily Times, 9/8/1892.


THE SONGS OF BURNS.

At the Choral Hall last evening, under the patronage of the Burns Club and in aid of St Andrews Manse bazaar fund, Miss Marion S. W White, M.A. delivered, before a fairly numerous audience, a lecture on "The Songs of Burns." The Rev. Rutherford Waddell presided.

Miss White prefaced an interesting and able lecture by remarking that anybody who took Burns as a subject laid himself or herself open to two serious objections, the first of which was that everything had been already said about Burns not once but a hundred times and the second was almost the opposite - that many people did not like Burns. The second objection, Miss White said, emboldened her to ignore the first, which, however, she immediately proceeded to dispose of, as she showed by her lecture that however much has been said about the national poet of Scotland, it was possible still to deal with the subject in a fresh and attractive light To the life and character of Burns the lecturer made only an incidental reference, remarking that in him self control was wanting, and that the power to act as his moral and religious nature prompted him was not present. The bulk of the lecture was devoted to a thoughtful discussion of the poet's songs, many of which she recited. It is not for every person to pronounce Scotch correctly, and it will perhaps not be regarded as hypercritical if we say that Miss White is not one of those who possess the gift; but for all that her reading of the songs was pretty and effective. She was frequently interrupted during the lecture by demonstrations of approbation, and when she sat down the applause was hearty and prolonged. 

The Chairman, at the conclusion of the lecture expressed the thanks of his congregation to Miss White for preparing her lecture and delivering it that evening. She had not only the heart to appreciate the poet, but she had also an excellent method of expressing her sentiments and thoughts regarding him. The speaker fears that Scotch was becoming a dead language, and he found that amongst the young colonials there were many who did not understand it and did not care for it. He was a Scotchman himself - that was, perhaps, his misfortune rather than his fault - but he had an intense sympathy with Burns, and it was very gratifying to him to see a distinguished student of the Otago University giving such an appreciative lecture upon Burns' songs. 

Incidental to the lecture, Miss H D Matheson sang "Aye, wakin' O," Miss L Tresseder "o wert thou in the cauld blast" (for which she received an encore), Miss Alice Grey "My heart is sair" (a portion of which, in response to the demands of the audience, she had to repeat), Mr J. H. Nimmo "Scots wha hae," Mr A. Walker "My love is like a red, red, rose," and Mr A. Wright "My Nannie's awa."  The duet "Ye banks and braes" was sung by Misses A. Cooper and M. Owen, and an encore had to be granted, while a double quartet of male voices  received encores for their renderings of "Wullie brewed a peck o' malt" and "Duncan Gray." The singing of "Auld lang syne" appropriately concluded the programme, for the musical portion of which Miss Lily Cameron acted as accompaniste.  -Otago Daily Times, 12/10/1892.


A Milton Lassie. — We are delighted to welcome back among us, albeit only for a time, our talented young townswoman, Miss Marion White, M.A., who has been gaining laurels down North as a lecturer, her theme being the poetry of Robert Burns. Miss White will lecture in Milton, and we can assure our readers there is a treat in store for them. The Dunedin press speaks in the highest terms of praise of her entertainment, which comprises music and singing, as well as oratory. As Miss White is a "Milton High School girl" Tokomairiro generally ought to rally to her support when she faces her audience in St. George's Hall next month.   -Bruce Herald, 18/10/1892.



THREE MONTHS' RELIEVING.

(Specially Written for the Witness Christmas number of 1893.)

 By MARION S. W. WHITE,

It was a wild night on the Gray Ranges. The wind, sweeping across the tussocked slopes in furious gusts, drove before it the keen rain, and twisted the meek shrubs and lashed the yellow tufts of snowgrass, as if furious that it had no worthier object for its wrath. No star was visible, and the moon, buried somewhere behind the hurrying masses of black cloud, was too young as yet to have more than the faintest influence on the stormy darkness. The hills sloped down abruptly to the river, which, swollen with the rains, roared and thundered over its rocky bed with that ominous and uncanny rise and fall of sound that fascinates the night listener. A narrow bridle track led over the hills, and was apparently continued down the precipitous slope to the river. But the rider who had last made use of it dismounted at the top of the incline, and, instead of beginning the descent, leaned with one hand on her horse's neck and listened to the noise of the river. For her the roar down there in the darkness bad a very real and human terror. She had never been here before. She knew nothing about the depth or danger of the stream. But she did know that it had to be crossed before she could reach shelter. Her horse was a hired one, and she had doubts of its powers. Her riding habit was soaked; her little close riding cap was dripping upon her white cheeks and broad eyelids. She could feel the cold rain against her head, through cap and veil and coiled-up hair. Her feet were numb, and the small hand on the horse's neck was almost lifeless.

"It's well you aren't inclined to run away, old Spider," the girl said, with a pat to the wet neck, "for I shouldn't be able to hold you in with these hands."

Spider had no intention of running away. But possibly he wished that he had had, instead of a light and gentle stranger, one of his own familiar rough-handed riders, who would have sworn at him and held his head up, and rattled him home to stable and supper, instead of standing and patting him in the bitter wind and rain. He moved restlessly, and pawed the narrow path, looking sideways at his perplexed companion. "We can't go back," she said, "15 miles against this storm. We can't stay here and be turned into pillars of ice, like Lot's wife. If we go on we must cross that river. And it roars like ten thousand lions for their prey. I wonder if you have crossed it before, and if you can swim, old Spider; for I can't. Come, then; I'll lead you down."

She took the bridle, and began to step carefully down the slippery track, the horse picking his way behind her. Soon the bordering of their way changed from tussocks to bush, and the girl clung to manuka and mappo as the horse slipped and slid and struggled down. The darkness in the gorge was intense, and the sound of the water grew so close as they descended that the girl expected momentarily to feel the cold flood round her feet. The noise surrounded and stunned her. She lost that half of her courage which had proceeded from a want of realisation of the danger; and as she clambered on — now dragging her horse, now dragged by him, with her habit tangling in the tree stumps, and the wild brambles pulling above at her cap and hair like elfish hands — Dorothy Graeme thought one or two unspoken prayers of characteristic simplicity and earnestness. "Help me not to be afraid, and comfort Jack if I am drowned."

At last, and yet suddenly, she found herself trembling on the river bank, and peering through the rain at the strange, black moving thing that lay across her path. She tried to judge of its width, but it was so dark that she could not distinguish river from bank. Dorothy felt a sudden weakness, and put her hand up to shut out the incessant noise and the moving darkness. But Spider pricked his ears, shook himself, and sniffed at the water with the cheerful alacrity of a good horse who sees only a trifling and familiar obstacle between himself and his supper. Dorothy seized on the omen, shook the rain from her hair, and decided that the bugbear was a mere creek, perhaps not up to the horse's knee. She tried girths and bridle, mounted from a stone, and felt Spider splash cautiously but firmly into the stream.

It was deep, and the current was strong. They were carried down with it, but the horse kept his feet. The water rose to his girths, and Dorothy's long habit, caught in the flow, almost dragged her from the saddle. She gathered it up hastily, and spoke cheerily to the horse and patted his neck. He stepped strongly, but the river grew deeper at each step — deeper and deeper, till she dipped her right hand in it to the wrist. She felt the horse gather himself together with a strain. Then the ground went from under his feet, and Dorothy, clinging to mane and pommel, shrieked a desperate "Save me!" to the wind and rain. But she was not drowning. Spider had got out of his depth, and was swimming for his life. In a moment she saw the outline of the bank. The next, something seemed to rise from the river and push her by both shoulders from the saddle. She fell face downwards without a cry, grasped at a projection with the grip of desperation, and heard in the same instant the sound of the horse's hoofs as he struggled up the rocky bank, and left his rider to die. She was only 19; she did not fear death, but to die thus terribly in the black water and the storm all alone! She screamed aloud to God. A human voice answered her through the rush and dash of rain and river. Presently she heard the words: 

"Keep quite still, and you'll be safe in half a minute." 

A hand touched her, an arm was put round her. 

"Now, loose your hold of the root. Lean on me. You feel the bottom? Hold my hands — we're safe!

They were safe. Dorothy lay — very weak, but quite conscious — on the wet rock, and a man was chafing her hands by the light of a lantern, while Spider stood dripping and trembling beside them.

As her rescuer looked anxiously at Dorothy's face she smiled back faintly and half raised her head.

"You're better?" he asked, smiling too. "You had a very cold bath. I wish I could offer you my coat, but it is as wet as the river."

"Thank you," said Dorothy very weakly, but smiling again. "I'll soon be better. Are we very far from shelter?"

"Not half a mile. There's a farmhouse at the top of this hill. I could easily carry you up." "Oh, I can ride," Dorothy said, "if you will help me to mount."

The stranger looked dubious, but he helped her to rise with care, and lifted her into the saddle. Dorothy was weaker than she knew, and it needed all the care of her companion to keep her safely there. The rain was still heavy, but they were sheltered from the wind, and as Spider climbed stiffly up the long hill Dorothy felt through all her physical discomfort a sense of protection and security that shortened the halfmile surprisingly.

"I should not have come alone," Dorothy said in apology for her weight against the arm that supported her; "I am the relieving teacher appointed to Gany School, and arrived in Rainville to-day with the coach. There was no one to meet me, so I borrowed poor Spider and set out to ride. It seemed to get dark and stormy very suddenly." "It did indeed," said her companion; and his voice had an anxious intensity of feeling that arrested Dorothy through all her own preoccupation. She said nothing for a minute, trying to find some words wherein to utter her thanks. But while she hesitated the lights of a house streamed out a few feet farther on, and the barking of half a dozen dogs brought out a man and a whip to ascertain the reason of the disturbance. Dorothy's companion did not call him, but helped her hastily down, knocked loudly at the door, and as steps were heard coming along the passage, turned, with a hasty "Good night!" and strode away into the darkness.

The relieving teacher at Gany had been for a week in the enjoyment of her new dignities, when on a Friday afternoon she opened the door of her little schoolroom, and watched the children stream out into the mild autumn sunlight. They smiled at her as they went past, for they liked the new schoolmistress. She moved about after they were gone, putting away a book or two, and picking up a withered flower or a dropped slate-pencil here and there. There was a cup of hollyhocks and sweet-peas standing on her desk. She lifted it and buried her little straight nose in the fragrant pink blossoms. Then she locked the desk, and stood for a minute looking out on the grassy clearing and the path that wound through it and disappeared in the bush. In a few moments she would go into her own bare little house, and prepare her solitary cup of tea and cut her slice of bread-and-butter. Then she would walk perhaps a little way through the bush or over the hills, and gather some fresh ferns and wild daisies. Returning, she would prepare certain notes and lessons for to-morrow, write a letter or two, read a few pages of her novel, lock up her house, and go to bed. To-morrow would be as to-day, and each after day as tomorrow. Dorothy smiled pensively, contemplating the story of her three months. "I won't have much to tell Jack," she said. The thought of Jack brought up the swift colour, though she was all alone. It did not bring a happy smile with it. Dorothy knitted her white brows in a vexing perplexity over that name. She was to decide now, in these three months of absence and loneliness, about Jack. She had promised to decide. She would surely find out, when she was so far away from him, whether or not — whether or not. She beat her pink finger-tips upon the dim little pane in impatience. She had known Jack all her life. How could she find out — whether or not? And yet, Jack loved her so! Why would boys love people so, and be so desperately in earnest?

She turned from the window in a little pet at life and lovers, and went out into the afternoon sunshine. She did not care for tea just now. She would walk across the hill, and taste the clear, mild air.

When one person climbs a hill from one side and another person climbs it from the opposite one, there is a strong probability that they will meet at the top. So it came to pass that Dorothy, standing with bright cheeks at the summit of her hill, came face to face with someone she had seen before.

"Oh, I am so glad!" she said, and held out a soft hand to her saviour of a week ago. "Why are you so glad?" he asked, just touching the hand, and looking down on the face, with its brilliant smile and its great eyes.

"Because I have wanted so much to thank you, though I can't do it as I should." The eloquent grey eyes pleaded for the helpless tongue. "You saved me from drowning, and I never saw you again to say a word of thanks."

"Perhaps after all it is I who should say the words of thanks," the stranger said, smiling with a strangely melancholy sweetness at the eager face. "But supposing it otherwise, I shall be a thousand times repaid if you will talk to me a little."

Dorothy looked with some wonder at the man who uttered words of such unusual courtesy on the bare hills of Gany. His face, she decided, was no contradiction to his easy grace of speech — a delicate, refined face, worn as it seemed with thought or care, and intensely melancholy in repose; two dark, enigmatic eyes, with a steadfast attentiveness of gaze that yet had not the faintest trace of impertinence. Dorothy was frank and fearless by nature and by training, but she felt a sudden inexplicable failure of her courage before the grave regard of these sad eyes. She wished, without any reason for it, that she could guess at his age. Was he 30, 40? It didn't matter.

"I'm afraid I can't talk very well unless you will tell me your name," Dorothy said, with first her open eyes and then her downcast eyelids to atone for the abruptness of the request.

"My name is Kenneth Austin," her companion said; "and your poor servant ever." he added smiling, and bowing to the dainty picture before him. Dorothy rejoined with a courtesy and a "Sir, my good friend!" like a queen of fair maids, as she was.

So they walked together over the barren hills, and talked together under the smiling autumn sky. They spoke of books, of men, and places. Austin had seen much and read and reflected more. But it was not the store of information and thought that every word revealed which fascinated Dorothy. It was the subtle, perfect sympathy of this soul with her own. She spoke from her heart. Fancies and dreams that she had never before put into words came now to her tongue clothed in delicate speech. Something in her companion's deep eyes and sombre voice drew forth all that was bright, earnest, noble, or fantastic in the girl's full, fluent inward life. She had always lived among intelligent people. Often she had talked with men of learning and culture; but she had never felt before this exquisite communion of spirit with spirit when all barriers seemed melted away, and her intellect was free to speak its own language. Her eyes shone like stars, and her clear soul came to their windows to look upon this other chance-met fellow soul with whom it found so much in common.

A strange walk and talk it seemed. Later, when they had parted in the shadow of the schoolhouse, Dorothy had come down from her golden exaltation to the chillier present. Austin had not talked of himself so far as the events of his own history went. She know nothing more of his kin or possessions now than she had known when he called to her from the bank of the Gany. But how fine a soul! she thought, clasping her hands anew, and remembering the simplicity, the generosity, the nobility of all this man's views. Were there many such here among the farmers and shepherds, whose children came daily in their heavy boots or bare brown feet to school? She would think better of all human beings, she fancied, because this stranger had so lofty and so pure a mind.

She fell to wondering whether her old friends at home would understand her appreciation. Jack, for instance — what would Jack say? She had a letter from him lying on the table. She read it again and threw it down impatiently. It seemed so trite, so petty, so raw and boyish after that grave voice. Then she picked it up again, with tears, and kissed it. Jack loved her, after all; and there are so few people in the world who love us! She would answer the letter to-morrow, and say only that the stranger who had saved her life was intelligent, perhaps, and kind-hearted. Jack would not mind that — poor old jealous Jack, who clouded down whenever she bowed to anyone else on the street. 

The matrons of Gany, with the best intentions in the world, were not able, owing to long distances, numerous children, and many domestic duties, to keep a very careful eye on the movements or their teacher. But the children, tumbling about the hills and scrambling through the bush after school hours, not unfrequently saw Miss Graeme employed, only with more dignity, in much the same pursuit. Sometimes she was alone; but now and then someone accompanied her and carried the ferns and berries that she valued. For their talk together on the hill above the school was not their last. Their last! Would their last talk come some day? Dorothy found the thought of it aching strangely, constantly in her heart. She had only three weeks longer to stay. How the days had flown! How soon she must leave the little tranquil school, and the cool bush, and the wild hills, and her free, solitary life!

And she would never go back to quite the life she had left; for she must write to Jack, and tell him whether or not. Tomorrow she would write. To-night the sky was wild and the wind stormy. She would go out and walk a little — walk away the strange fever of regret and grief which the thought of her departure woke. She went out and climbed the hill, as she had done two months ago, struggling against the wind with a certain defiant pleasure. She looked back across there two months to the girl that climbed the hill then. She felt so much older now, so much wiser and larger in her views; and that must be because she had talked now and then to Kenneth Austin. How much he had taught her and shown her, and how soon she was going away!

She walked over the hill to the shelter of a huge rock, and stood, hidden from the wind, beside it. Someone who had been watching her came too. Kenneth Austin smiled his melancholy smile at the young, bright-eyed friend, who flushed so softly at his coming.

They had often met thus — the world-worn, sombre man and the clear-eyed girl. What tie bound them to each other, of trust, and pity, and admiration, neither knew, but to-day it was to be broken. Austin's face was pale and strange. Dorothy felt, with her quick instinct, that something was to be said or done that would end or alter their friendship. She did not speak.

"I have been watching for you," said Austin, very gently. "I must tell you something to-day. I have always known I must tell it, since that night when you smiled on the rock."

"Yes," Dorothy said, unsteadily.

"You are very lovely, and your eyes have a light in them from Heaven above. I think sometimes that you must have come from Heaven to make me confess my sin and save my soul."

Dorothy's eyes spoke only.

"You have been good to me and sweet, and my life since you came has been paradise. Paradise with a serpent, though," he said, with a kind of bitter laugh; "the serpent of my sin."

"Tell me of it," Dorothy said, with her sweet voice and her clear eyes of pity to help the bitter confession.

"Do you know why I live in a hut in the bush and have neither friend nor brother to turn to? I was wicked; I gambled away my chances in this world and the next. I broke my father's heart, and wore out the patience of God's angels. They left me alone, and I — I forged a cheque, and another man suffers the punishment for it to this day. I hide here from the shame and the agony of my cowardice. But that night — the night you came — when the wind blew and the river roared, and the trees strained and creaked in the storm, ten thousand fiends rose up and cursed me for my crime, and I saw the face of that man in prison as I see yours now. When the clock struck 9 I took up my lantern and walked to the river, and I was walking straight in when you called."

Involuntarily Dorothy clasped the arm that had saved her with her two hands as if to draw him back from his dark fate. He looked down at the hands on his sleeve, and then at the true eyes raised to his. "What must I do?" 

"You must take his place and set him free."

Her own voice sounded like a stranger's in her ears. "And I will never see you again?" "How long will it be?" 

"Ten years. But I am a dying man now. I will not live it through." 

"Oh, pray to God! — to God. There is no one to help us on earth!"

"I will pray. I am not afraid of God now, since I have seen you. The angels have your eyes when they plead with God for us." 

"And if you live — if you come back — we will meet?" 

"We will meet sooner. I cannot live two years with this heart....Then I will say good-bye." 

"Must you go now?" 

"Now. May God love you, my sister, my good angel." 

"And you, my brother, my friend." 

They kissed each other solemnly, with tears. Then a gust of sudden fury drove round the rock, and Dorothy was alone. 

"What good did it do, Jack?" she said, years after, telling of that meeting and parting, when the daisies were white on Kenneth Austin's grave.

"It saved a soul, I think," said Jack. "When girls are like my Dorothy, the lost see to walk straight by the whiteness of their lives."  -Otago Witness, 21/12/1893.


THE WOMAN BOOM.

By Marion S. W. White, M.A. 

"The subject for discussion to-day," said the President of the Fish and Fly Discussion Society, "is the Woman Boom," 

There was a dead silence. 

"The — I don't think I quite caught the title," Millicent said at last in a faint voice. 

"The Woman Boom," repeated the President firmly. Three members of the society, and Freddie, rose to their feet. "Will you excuse me, I had forgotten an engage..." 

But the President waved them back to their places with an inexorable hand. 

"It is of no use," she said, and when she spoke in that tone nobody dared to resist her. "We must discuss it. We have done 'The Future of New Zealand,' the 'Coming Australian Novelist,' 'Spiritualism,' 'Theosophy,' and 'Our Neighbours' Faults.' The other great subject of the day is the Woman Boom, and if we neglect it we are shirking a duty. Freddie, sit down." 

Freddie's enemies say that he is "harmless," but his friends indignantly deny the accusation. He is admitted to the discussions of the society chiefly because he won't go away and fish. The society has another fine feature besides Freddie. Although everyone is bound to discuss, nobody is ever compelled to have an opinion, or to arrive at a conclusion. So that its arguments do not flow in keen, clear streams, but drop like dews from the eaves of a thatched cottage.

"If you are going to discuss Woman with a capital letter," said Freddie very decidedly, "I have an engagement. Woman with a small 'w,' " he added, looking pathetically round upon the society, "is an angel; but woman with a capital is a bore. All I ask is, has this one a capital?"

"We shall discuss her with a small letter," said the President placably. Freddie heavy a sigh of relief and sank back upon the grass. The society had just finished a spirited cray-fishing competition. They were now sitting or lying about the bank of the stream, waiting for the billy to boil. By the laws of the society all discussions had to take place in the open air, because, as the President fondly believed, the smells of manuka and the songs of tuis destroy prejudice and promote generous views of life. 

"First," said the President, "we shall take definitions. Millicent, what is the Woman Boom?" 

"It is the effort," said Millicent, "that women are making under the guidance of a few fanatics to usurp all the duties and privileges of men. On paper it is a collection of all the tedious and unprofitable questions ever invented. In tram cars and railway trains it is the strong-minded woman with the bagful of tracts on the franchise. In the atmosphere it is a frightful fuss." 

"Your definitions are all hostile," said the President. "Mary, it is your turn." 

"The Woman Boom," said Mary, "is a nickname given in contempt by smallminded and ignorant people to the noble efforts women in our day are making towards enlightenment, freedom, and a larger ideal of living. Its leaders are brave women who face in a good cause the prejudice, apathy, and insult of their own sex and the brutal hostility of the other." 

"Doris, give your definition," said the President. 

"It is dress reform, isn't it? and cycling and smoking cigarettes on the balcony, and wearing tailor-made frocks, with those dear neckties that suit Millicent so well." Thus Doris, and poked out her foot to admire its instep. 

"Freddie, define the Woman Boom." 

"Woman — the female of the human race," said Freddie, quoting his dictionary. "boom — to roll, to roar, as cannon, thunder, &c. Woman Boom, the rolling and roaring of the female of the human race. What's the matter, Mary?" 

"Women are not whales," Mary said with great scorn; "besides, dictionary definitions are lazy. You must make one yourself. Make a metaphor." 

"The Woman Boom," said Freddie promptly, "is fuss. And fuss is the smoke of the factory where progress is manufactured. It is like other smoke — very unwholesome and spoils the scenery, but can't be helped." 

"Your grammar is loose, Freddie, but your sentiments do you credit," said the President approvingly. 

"Now I shall give you my definition. The Woman Boom is the latest and most dangerous phase of class feeling. We see the working of class feeling between the rich and poor, between employers and labourers, and between the white and the dark races. Now the Woman Boom is the introduction of this hostile and bitter sentiment between man and woman. The literature of the Woman Boom always treats men as a class, and women as a class. Some authors praise women and blame men. Others deify men and defame women. But you will find this principle of disunion and antagonism in all the writing on both sides. Mary, dear, push a stick against the billy lid to see if it is shaking. If it is, that means that the water is boiling. If not, come back and say something." 

The billy was not boiling, and Mary spoke, leaning against a broad leaf tree and looking very much in earnest.

"I think," she said, "that if people would look at the conditions of a woman's life fairly, without being prejudiced in their views by their fastidious taste and dislike of load noises" (here she glanced at Millicent), "they would see that women are unfairly treated. They are trammelled by conventions all their lives. If they are single, their lives are narrow and dreary, and they are sneered at for not having captured husbands; if they are married, they are often household drudges, bound to their kitchens and nurseries, with no time for books, or for anything higher than a gossip over a new dress." (Here Mary's eye fell on Doris, who, however, is not married.) "I honour and applaud the efforts that are being made towards equality and a free field for men and women alike." 

The President knitted her brows. 

"When you talk of household drudgery," she began, "I often wonder what picture you have in your mind of a man's daily work. Your husband kisses you in the morning. I beg your pardon, dears — I mean he will kiss you, and goes to work. You begin to dust the dining room (although certainly that should be done before breakfast) and to make the pudding and darn the socks; and you sigh and envy men their freedom. But where are the men all day?" The President here made a rhetorical pause, but no one venturing to account for the absent husbands, she resumed: "They are working in factories — candle factories, jam factories perhaps, or standing behind counters pulling down the same two dozen rolls of tweed, silk, calico, nun's veiling, and delaine hour after hour and day after day, for the same 20 types of customers to look at and sniff over; or they sit in offices and add up figures on pain of dismissal if they forget what they ought to carry; or they plough, or harrow, or mend sod fence, or ride after droves of bullocks at three miles an hour in the dust and the wind. I don't say, remember, that dusting the room or making the salad is exciting or ennobling. But I think most people, if they thought it over, would rather do that than many of the things men do. Freddie, wake up!" 

"Freddie woke with a start. "That's what I say," he remarked cordially; "and as for old maids, the nicest people I know in the world, except four, are old maids." 

"Nobody spoke of old maids," said the President calmly, "but since you are awake, say something about the heroines of the Woman Boom Books." 

Freddie made a grimace. "I don't mind reading about them," he said cautiously, trying to keep the emphasis from falling on the fourth word. "Could you fall in love with them?" "No, unless there was nobody there out of the other books." 

"You pay them a high compliment." murmured Mary.

"They have bad tempers mostly," said Freddie, with a yawn, "and bad manners. I'll tell you now," he added with more animation, "what I don't like about them. What relation should you say Woman, with a capital, is to Man, with a capital?" 

"His sister," said Doris, 

"Closer than that." 

"His mother." 

"Yes. The Universal Woman is the Universal Man's mother. And if her son has all those faults the new authoress accuses him of, she should forgive him and love him as our mothers do. She shouldn't howl at him and show him up as if he was somebody else's little boy." 

"I think," said Millicent, "the reason why I dislike this subject so much is that it is ruining literature. We have good novelists still, but we never get a good novel. The moment that the New Woman is introduced, either in fun or in earnest, she ruins the book. Poetry is dead."

"That follows naturally from my definition," said the President. "The Woman Boom is a wedge inserted between man and woman — there is Freddie asleep again — and such a division is as antagonistic to poetry as the amputation of a leg. The secret of poetry is that it has the power of seeing everything in its entirety. The poet sees a man and a woman as one perfect creature. Their two souls together form the soul of humanity. The woman boomers see a man and a woman as representatives of two opposing classes, requiring to be armed against each other. Good gracious they are all asleep." 

"No, I am not," said Doris; "I have just remembered something that often puzzles me when I hear people talking. There is an argument, isn't there, that women are inferior to men in various faculties because they have never been educated like men - because their mothers were ignorant, they are ignorant?" 

"It is quite true," said Mary. "To be born a woman is to be born under the weight of the thousand disadvantages which have been heaped upon our sex for centuries." 

"But," objected Doris, "this is what puzzles me. A boy and a girl might be twins. The boy might take after his mother and the girl after her father. Then would the boy inherit all the disadvantages from his mother and the girl all the advantages from her father? Suppose the father to be very clever and learned, or very inventive, or sensible, or musical, wouldn't the girl get the best chance of having a brilliant future?" 

"Education would ruin her chance," said Mary, dodging the original question very sweetly. 

"Ah, but I am thinking only of heredity just now," Doris exclaimed; "every girl is the daughter of her mother and her father, and every boy is the son of his father and his mother. Will anyone explain to me  how the centuries of oppression can affect the one more than the other? It always seems to me that they start quite fair when they are babies at any rate." 

"The billy is boiling," announced Mary. 

"Well," said the President, "I wish to say something before we make tea. Mary, you spoke of a want of freedom and of trammels and conventions weighing upon women. Now, I wish you all this year to test how many of these trammels are real, and how many exist only in the writings of the woman boomers. I do not say that women are free everywhere, but I do say that in our own country there are no restrictions placed upon a woman but such as rest on every human being — the restrictions of timidity and incapacity. What profession is closed to a New Zealand woman?"

"Politics," said Mary boldly. 

The President shook her head. "Parliament is closed to us at this moment," she said, "but everyone knows that if three women could be found in the two islands with a genius for statesmanship they would be admitted to the House within the year. I say again there are no conventions against us but such as we ourselves subscribe to; and so there need not be any smoke from our progress factory unless we really like smoke." 

"And I think," went on the President, "that we should all try not to drive in that wedge of disunion any deeper. Women are often unhappy and discontented, and their lives are narrow and their ambitions cramped. But all those conditions rest upon men too, although there has not as yet been a special man boom to wail over them. Women, as a sex, have ugly faults; but only women, as individuals, will ever cure them. Here come the men with a trout. Freddie, quick, the frying pan. Mary, the butter." 

"We have not come to any conclusions, have we?" asked Millicent. 

"No one ever does on this subject," said the President composedly, spooning butter into the pan. "And no one acquainted with the society would expect, it on any subject." added Mary, unpacking the cups.  -Otago Witness, 17/1/1895.


Educational

MISS MARION S. W. WHITE, M.A., University Coach and Private Tutor. Special terms for pupil teachers. — Address care of J. L. Salmond, architect, 27 Rattray Street.   -Otago Daily Times, 30/1/1895.


LITERATURE CLASS. 

— Second Quarter Opens May 8, at 3 p.m., Mrs Wilkie's Rooms, Stuart street. Books, "Our Mutual Friend" and "Twelfth Night." Fee, One Guinea. — Marion S. W. White, M. A.  -Otago Daily Times, 7/5/1895.


NATURAL MAGIC.

(Written for the Otago Witness Christmas Number of 1895.) 

By MARION S. W. WHITE, M.A. 

We do not keep half-holidays on the station for every trifle — royal birthdays and other national anniversaries do not disturb the even tenor of our way; but when the news is brought up to the homestead That "Dick Springer is at the hut," joy thrills in every breast, and everybody decides upon having pressing business that day in the neighbourhood of the stockyard. For Dick Springer is the horsebreaker, the Bland Holt, Brough and Boucicault, and Wild West Shew of the back settlements, whom not to know, by report at least, argues thyself unknown; and whom not to see argues thyself some form of pitiful simpleton. 

So all the rabbiters, shepherds, and stockmen who can by any means shirk their legitimate occupations, together with the governess, the children, and the visitors, secure reserved seats on the stockyard fence, and take an observation of Dick Springer while the horses are brought in. He is half-French, half-English by extraction, but colonial born and bred. He is of middle height, thin, fair-complexioned, and active-looking, with that indefinable alert finish to his voice and features which is gained only by intercourse with horses. He carries a long stockwhip, and places some thongs, straps, and ropes in the corner of the yard under the cow-bail. 

Here come the horses, cantering down the flat, in front of the cow man's old black mare and the manager's big, bad-tempered chestnut. There are a dozen of them, all fresh from the hills, and almost as ignorant of humanity and its trammels as the wild horses of a Mexican prairie. They stare and snort disdain at the fences and faces, but with a few flickings of the whip and a few shouts, three of their number are selected for manipulation, and the rest are left outside in the paddock to moralise until their own turn comes.

Of the three, one is a dark bay colt, with an anxious, honest face, like a good country boy who has lost himself in town; the second a longtailed cream filly, with a "dark rolling e'e," like Annie Laurie's; and the third a sullen young draught, who doesn't mean to be broken in if he can help it. The filly and the draught are shut up in a narrow side wing of the yard, and the bay is left alone to face his trainer. 

For the first 20 minutes Dick Springer does nothing but stand in the middle of the yard cracking his stockwhip, as if he were practising to himself. The colt, who takes every sound for the crack of doom, rushes from side to tide, seeking escape and finding none. His coat is shining wet, and his eyes are protruding with terror. When he stops after a frantic rush the horsebreaker shouts at him, and he makes another rush in the other direction, until at last he is blind, and stupid, and giddy with despair. Then the horsebreaker, laying aside the whip, takes up a long manuka wattle, and approaches the colt, chanting "Wo-ho the Pet! wo-ho the Pet!" in a curious sort of sing-song that goes up in the middle and down at the end, and has all the accent on the "ho." At first the Pet moves off, but in a dizzy, uncertain way, and very soon he has allowed the horsebreaker to touch him with the tip of his wattle. From the moment when he submits to that touch the colt is a changed animal. Very soon he is allowing Dick Springer to rub his back up and down with the stick, to the soothing music of "Wo-ho the Pet!" Presently the stick is laid aside, and the colt is being tickled on the face and neck with a bunch of tussock grass. He enjoys this, and stands like a pet lamb, with his head down, to be caressed. Gradually the touch of a human hand is substituted for the tussock, and the horsebreaker stands petting and rubbing the poor frightened "new boy," and consoling him with the most endearing epithets. But while Dick Springer calls the colt his lamb and his darling, he is artlessly fastening round his neck a halter with a long rope attached. Then he pulls his ears, rubs his protruding face muscles, claps him on the back, creeps under him, handles his legs, and makes him lift his feet. After this, whatever sufferings and terrors Dick may inflict upon him, the colt is always willing to be loved and petted again.

Up to this point the colt's sufferings have been purely mental. But now comes the three-legged dance. The trainer straps up each of his four legs in turn, and drives him round and round the yard. The colt staggers and plunges, mad with fright, while his two comrades in the side wing paw and snort with indignant sympathy. Sometimes, in sheer despair, the colt lies down to die, but he is immediately petted, patted, and chanted to until he gets up and faces life again. After this severe experience is over his expression is one of mingled reproach and resignation, and he accepts endearments as one prophetically foreseeing horrors. 

Dick Springer straps a girth round the colt, and substitutes a head halter for the neck halter; then he jumps on the colt's back over the tail, like a clown. The colt bucks. The rider says, "Wo-ho the Pet!" with friendly encouragement, and guides the colt, who is blind with excitement, away from the fence rails and bail posts. The colt's performance is so powerful and so genuine that we retire from the front row of the dress circle and take our observations from a very safe distance. The whole yard has turned into a colt and his rider, who are everywhere at once; we had never dreamt that a horse had so much of the kangaroo in bis unregenerate nature. However, pig-jumping and kicking both fail to move the serenity of that weight on the colt's back, and at last he lies down in the dust and tries to roll it off. Then it gets off of its own accord, pets, flatters, and caresses as before, and turns the colt into the stableyard, invested with a saddle, a bridle, and a crupper, all equally abhorrent to a freeborn taste.

The little filly takes her turn next. She begins like a demon, but yields sooner, than either of the others to the chant and the caressing. When the three are girthed and bitted they will allow no one to go near them except their trainer, and him they come to meet like affectionate dogs. 

It takes Dick Springer three days to break in a horse to saddle and harness. To-morrow he will ride the colt up and down the paddocks. He will tie sheepskins to its tail, dangle white rags to its rein, open and shut umbrellas on its back, and otherwise prepare it in advance for all the frights and starts of an active equine career. Incidentally he will teach it to come at a whistle or a snap of the fingers, and to follow, unled, like a dog. On the third day he will drive it in harness, submitting it to every variety of fright that experienced ingenuity can suggest, and after that the colt is broken in. The process is a brief condensation of all the miseries, terrors, and agonies a horse can suffer, inflicted with the tenderest hand and voice in the world, and all, like Petruchio's taming of his shrew, "under name of perfect love." 

After these experiences the horse is genuinely "broken in," requiring only that care and attention which all young animals demand to be perfectly reliable. Dick Springer is not vain of his achievement, but after witnessing it I incline to think there's something more than natural in it if philosophy could find it out.  -Otago Witness, 19/12/1895.


MISS MARION S. W. WHITE, M.A., 

RESUMED TEACHING, February 4, No. 3 Bellevue terrace, George street. Pupils prepared for University, Civil Service, and Teachers' Examinations.   -Otago Daily Times, 8/2/1896.


Educational.

THE LADIES' LITERATURE CLASS 

will REOPEN WEDNESDAY, February 26, at 3 o'clock, at 3 Bellevue Terrace, George street. Fee, One Guinea. Books: "The Woman in White," "Vailima Letters," and "Two Gentlemen of Verona." MARION S. W. WHITE, M.A.   -Otago Daily Times, 25/2/1896.


ABOVE THE MOSQUITOES.

By Marion S. W. White, M.A.

It was somebody's chance remark that mosquitoes cannot live more than 2000ft above the sea-level which first suggested to us the advisability of climbing Mount Waiapehu. For weeks the mosquitoes had been our inseparable companions. They slept with us, ate with as, went swimming with as, played tennis with us, accompanied us to garden parties, picnics, and morning calls. We went to visit Maori Pahs, and before the Maori cur could bark a welcome or the lady of the house collect her English for a salutation, we saw the mosquito rising politely to receive us. We drove to a circus performance, and beheld in the lion's cage and on the performing pony's back the familiar form of our attendant fly. We came at last to believe of the mosquitoes what Kipling remarks of something else: 

Take 'old o' the wings o' the mornin', 

And flop round the earth till you're dead — 

But you won't get away from the tune that they play. 

So that, when we heard the above remark, we said we should go 2000ft above sea-level and try. One of those accurate people who delight in dashing human hopes, then asserted that, to his certain knowledge mosquitoes were to be found up to a height of four thousand feet above sea-level. But everyone admitted that, there could not be mosquitoes on the top of Waiapehu. It was generally allowed that no one, except surveyors, who did not count, had ever performed the ascent. Wild cattle were known to roam over the ridges. Wild horses, the descendants of a shipment which had swum ashore 20 years ago from a vessel wrecked on the West Coast, were supposed to inhabit a clearing somewhere near the top. Goat, pig, pigeon, eel, duck, kaka, and other game were picturesquely described as tumbling over each other. 

The man who wasn't going to tried vainly to discourage us. 

"How are you going to keep your meat fresh for a week?" 

We laughed at the idea. 

"We are not going to carry coals to Newcastle. The bush is alive with game. We shan't take any meat." 

"How will you manage when you get lost?" 

"We shan't get lost. We have a compass." 

This man was particular in inquiring how long we expected to be away. We told him 10 days at the utmost. He reckoned up the date and put it down in his notebook. 

"Then I'll start the relief expedition on the 9th of the month," he said gravely. He then wished us good-bye with a chastened pathos in his manner that might have thrown a shadow over timid hearts. But the mosquitoes were particularly active that evening, and our resolution was iron. 

The exact height of Waiapehu is given in the geography books, and may be found there by inquiring friends. But, lest they should incline to make light of our achievement, I would remind them that people who write geographies do not climb the mountains they speak of so glibly. If they did the heights of some peaks would soon be doubled. 

We left the town of Levin on a Monday morning, a band of gallant hearts, wellordered, calm, and brave. Our motto was Nelson's, "Waiapahu, or Westminster Abbey!" Our leader carried a gun, our sub-leader a rifle, the boy, or gamin (Pronounced deservedly game 'un), bore a fieldglass and a billhook; while among the remaining four of us were distributed billies, baskets, and pieces of mosquito-netting. Two horses bore our heavier baggage to the first camping ground.

I well remember the sensations with which we rested at noon beneath a blossoming rata, and ate our first open-air meal. How the elastic spirit, wearied of the luxuries of pampered civilisation, gloried in its privations, and summoned all its Spartan qualities to meet the hardy toils and meagre fare of pioneer life! We ate cold ham, duck, meat pies, fruit tarts with cream, egg sandwiches, biscuits, plum pudding, and Madeira cake, and, concluding our humble meal with a few bananas and nuts and pineapple, we flung ourselves for half an hour's repose upon the soft grass, and gazed through the tree tops at the glowing sky. It is significant of the spirit which animated our party that not a wish was expressed to turn back — not a whisper of discontent or disaffection was breathed by any one of us. Although we were more than an hour's tramp from home, and had entered the bush which clothes Waiapehu almost to the top, no one hinted at fear. It was thought, however, in view of the inroads made at a single meal upon our stores, that a little more food would be wanted for a 10 days' sojourn. So our leader borrowed 12lb of biscuits from a bushman's hut in the neighbourhood. The bushman himself was not at home, so that no needless time was wasted in negotiations. As soon as the swags wore apportioned and rolled up, we set forth again upon the trail, leaving the horses to find their way home alone. Our leader now intimated that the next part of our journey lay up, or rather in, the Waimakaru River.

"But won't we get our feet wet?" I asked. The river is from 1ft to 10ft deep, and contains very large eels. "Ye-es, you'll get them a little damp," said the leader, stepping in. We got them very damp indeed; so damp, that we may now regard ourselves as living refutations of all those theories which tend to confirm a connection between wet feet and rheumatism, coughs, colds, bronchitis, catarrh, pleurisy, and tuberculosis. The five or six millions of mosquitoes who had so far formed our guard of honour now went home, after courteously introducing us to five or six millions of their relatives, who received us warmly and accompanied us up the river. These mosquitoes had never before tasted human blood, but they had evidently heard about it, and we judged by their conduct that they liked it very much. They were less noisy than their civilised brethren, but much more industrious, single-minded, and sociable,

There was very beautiful scenery up the river, but there were several obstacles to our enjoyment of it. My general impression is that we were in a deep gorge between two densely-wooded spurs, which ascended perpendicularly from the stream, and afforded shelter to wild boars. The stream itself flowed over a bed of slippery stones on which I repeatedly slipped and hurt myself; under fallen logs, which I climbed over with difficulty, or crawled beneath with great discomfort. Every now and then the river paused to form a deep clear pool, with an eel crawling over the bottom; or narrowed into a rapid torrent, in which I lost portion of my swag. The beautiful rata, which no lay of patriotic poet shall ever again persuade me to adore after finding that it is a despicable parasite, clung to the hillside; and the strip of blue sky above our beads looked down through a mist of mosquitoes.

River-wading is not hilarious work, and but for the gamin we might have been considered a very serious party. However, this child whistled all the music-hall ballads that ever were said or sung, always giving himself a double encore for "Where did you get that hat?" till we distinctly heard the tuis and mokies in the bush responding to each other with the same larrikin air. The dogs looked wistfully at the silent guns, and seemed to be reflecting on their chances of a supper. But we had not yet reached the happy hunting grounds where the game "had to be kicked out of your way." A pigeon — no, I retract the pigeon; I believe they are protected — a wild fowl of small dimensions fell to our gun, and was grilled on a stick a la Maori for tea. But judging from the fact that the gamin and I ate half of it to give us an appetite for the meal, I don't think the dogs could have got much. 

We lay round the camp fire and so did the mosquitoes. We sang songs; so did they. We recited Bulletin poetry; they called their friends to listen, and these came in their multitudes out of the dark forest, till every head was circled with a nimbus of gauzy wings and active legs. Then we applied to them a few well-selected adjectives and retired to the interior of our mosquito net; so did they. We remained awake all night; so did they. But whereas we arose at dawn, jaded, demoralised, and bumpy, they arose fresh, cheerful, and eager for the labours of the day. We may not love the mosquito, but we cannot help respecting him. 

We waded for another day up the river, and lived through another night of anguish on its bank, and at breakfast on the third day our leader announced that we should soon now begin the ascent of Waiapahu. Begin the ascent! We dared not look in each other's faces lest we should read our own thought there; we wanted to go home. 

The gamin spoke: "I think one day is the best length for a picnic," he said artlessly; "if it's too long you get tired of it."

We told him it was weak and base to cherish such thoughts, and demoralising to the party to express them.

Next day was spent in exploring for the route to the summit. We explored on biscuits. The mosquitoes explored with us. We saw pig-tracks, and shot a huia, but wherever the game was we might as well have been vegetarians for all the harm we did it. Slashing your upward way through dense bush is fatiguing work; but we had our reward. We reached at last the belt of birch — storm-tossed, starved, and loaded with moss where the mountain wind blows and the mosquito is no more. We looked at each other, pale with joy — and hunger. The peak of Waiapehu reared its friendly head on the right, and we perceived that its ascent from the river was only a matter of a day's climb. We also found the tracks of a large herd of cattle, and promised the dogs a feast tomorrow.

It was bitter work going down again to the haunts of the unloved. I happened to be walking last of the train on the climb down, and I got the accumulated mosquitoes of everybody else. It was a difficult position to fill with dignity.

Next day we took our blankets, some rice, and the remainder of the bushman's biscuits, and climbed Waiapehu. On its summit, which is covered with snowgrass tussock, and supports a trig very much out of the perpendicular, we pitched our camp. Below the snowgrass lies a belt of dwarf trees, crouching down from the weather; below these the birch, and below the birch the forest of miscellaneous trees, whose Maori names no southern pen can spell. We had one glimpse, and only one, of the plain which lies between the West Coast and the Ruahine Mountains. Lake Horowhenua looked a duck pond, and all the rich bush paddocks beds in a vegetable garden; westward blue sea stretched back to the blue sky, while to the south the dimmer blue of our own island broke the level vision. Before we had time to photograph the picture on our memories, the fog, rolling up over the ridges behind, came sweeping round our eyes and shut out everything but the gray-green tussock and the crooked trig. We gave it 20 hours to lift subsisting temperately on coffee and damper for that length of time. But it was a fog of unusual staying powers, and evidently meant us to lift first. So when damper had lost its novelty, and coffee its existence, we started to return home.

Our damper, I must observe, was made, not in digger style, but in the more picturesque fashion of the Maori. You mix your flour with water, salt, and soda. Take each a sharpened stick, and round one end twist your bit of dough like a furled flag. Fix the other end of the stick in the earth, and then contemplate the spectacle of seven little dampers bending sociably over a clear bed of embers and swelling in friendly rivalry into rolls. When they are cooked take them off the stick, fill the hole it leaves with butter (if you have any), and eat them with a thankful heart. If they are heavy, blame the soda; if they are burnt, blame the fire; if they are raw inside, give them to the dog behind you without attracting the other dog's attention. But never find fault with the man who mixed the dough, because that leads to misunderstanding, and destroys the harmony which should season a dinner of damper, with or without herbs.

When we were wider way again, finding our cut path through the dwarf bush and the fog, Rob, the pig-dog, provided us with a sensation. He retired into a strip of totara which ran up a gully close to our track, and sent out a large black, boar, with the gleaming tusks, bristling hair, and villainous aspect proper to the swine tribe. This animal trotted briskly across the triangle composed of the leader, the sub-leader, and myself, making an ineffectual "rip" at the sub's leg in passing. Before the rifle could be loaded he was under cover again with the three dogs following him through the tangled scrub.

We walked on along the track, listening to the dogs, and waiting for the boar to bail up. At least, I was told afterwards that that was how we were occupied. Personally, I was engaged in thinking about my obituary notice, in case the boar should suddenly appear at my feet, and bail me up. I had just decided that the writer would certainty leave out one of my initials when back a shout came through the fog, and travelled along the line. "Climb trees!" was the brief command. There were no trees to climb, but nobody stopped to argue the point. We got up on the surrounding vegetation to the height of a nursery chair, and waited. The gamin, who occupied a neighbouring perch, reported the fight. "I see him — Roy's got his hind leg. By strike, he is a whopper! Hear him champing his jaws — do you hear him? I say, he's ripped Rob's shoulder near off, the brute! There goes the rifle — he's over — he's not dead — he's going to fire again — hurray! Come on!"

I did not share the gamin's eagerness to be on the spot, because I have heard of wild animals feigning death so as to have a better chance at their enemies; but the sight of somebody with a pork ham in one hand and a pair of tusks in the other, satisfied me that the boar was dead enough for all practical purposes. We camped among the birch, and had grilled pork for tea. Wild cattle "mooed" around us, but the fog had turned into rain, which a high wind drove savagely through the tree-tops, and no hunting was possible. In spite of the boar interlude, we were rather depressed. Rob's wounds were grievous, though he was not the dog to make a fuss over them. The hissing drip of the rain into the camp fire and the roar of the wind through the bush, were hostile to the spirit of jollity. We asked the gamin for a story.

"There was a bloke in Wellington the other day," said the gamin; "he was drivin' an express, and there were some kids there. One o' them says to the bloke, 'Why don't you whip your horse?' and the bloke was a Yorkshireman, you know, and he says, 'My 'oss is a good 'oss. 'E don't need no whip!'" 

"Was it the bloke that said that or the kids?" asked the leaderette; "I didn't quite follow it." 

The gamin obligingly told it again. "Whose horse did you say it was, Gamin?" asked the sub-leader. "I missed that part." 

The gamin told it again. "I see it, all except the bit about the 'oss," said the leader.

The gamin repeated it, and then repeated it again for the English girl. 

Then we were ashamed, because the gamin had such honest confidence in our good faith. So we gave him the last inch of damper, and firmly quenched a rising inclination to ask for the story a sixth time. 

We dropped down to the river again next morning and resumed wading. The mosquitoes were very happy to welcome us back, but we trekked homeward so rapidly that they had hardly time to express their pleasure ere we were out of sight. The gamin covered himself with renown in an encounter with a second black boar which the dogs aroused on the river bank. It is, perhaps, due to myself to mention that I did not on this occasion feel any tremors for my life, because I was 10ft up a rata, and the boar looked nothing of an acrobat. The gamin, armed with a bill-hook, rushed up to the animal, hampered by the dogs, and slew him in single combat, like any gladiator fighting with wild beasts at Epheseus. It was a scene of gore and glory never to be forgotten, and the gamin, oblivious of hunger, wanted to stay out until he killed another pig.

We had left a depot at our first camp, which, when unearthed, provided us a sumptuous meal, and gave as strength to finish the homeward march. We went up in five days, and came back in 11 hours, which shows, not as some jealous people vulgarly suggest, that we dawdled when we had plenty of cake and marched when we were hungry, but merely that we got into excellent training in a very short time. The relief expedition, disappointed of its prey, is responsible for the slander that we camped all the time at the bushman's hut, but I candidly admit that we are responsible for the biscuits-Otago Witness, 5/3/1896.



A DISTRESSING SUICIDE.

A WELL-KNOWN YOUNG LADY POISONS HERSELF. 

On Saturday evening Miss Marion S. W. White, M.A., who resided with her two sisters in Bellevue Terrace, nearly opposite Knox Church, George street, was found dead in her bed under circumstances which point to the conclusion that she took her own life. In the morning her sisters went by the south express train into the country for a holiday at Berwick, leaving Miss White alone in the house. About half-past 7 p.m., a young man named Statham, whom she was coaching in his studies, called there and found a note under the door knocker addressed to himself. On reading the note he ascertained that the writer desired him to go for Mrs J. Wilkie and a doctor. He accordingly went to Mrs Wilkie and informed her of the contents of the letter. She thereupon sent Dr Macpherson to go to Miss White's house while she proceeded there at once herself. The doctor on arriving at the place found that Mrs Wilkie had been upstairs, and was under the impression that Miss White was very ill, but he saw at a glance that she was dead and had been so for an hour or two. On the chair beside the bed was a small hand mirror and a glass containing a few drops of something in the nature of poison, and it seemed evident that she had drunk whatever had been in the glass. A peculiar circumstance in connection with the affair is that the deceased had apparently made careful preparations for her death. She had taken off her clothing, folded it up, taken the counterpane off the bed, folded that, and then put it over her clothing. She had also covered the washstand over with a white cloth, and had finally, lain down upon the bed with her hair flowing about her shoulders. She was clad in her nightdress, and was covered by a sheet, while her face wore a calm and peaceful expression. There were plenty of poisons in the house, their presence being accounted for by the fact that the deceased studied chemistry. The doctor, however, was of opinion that death resulted from some powerful, quick-acting agent, and not from any of the poisons among the deceased's chemicals. It has transpired that on Saturday about noon the deceased went to a chemist's shop, taking with her an order from a J.P., and purchased an ounce of prussic acid, and the bottle which had contained it was empty. She had before taking the fatal draught written several letters, which were found in her desk. In one letter which was addressed to a medical gentleman in town (Dr Colquhoun) she analysed her mental feelings at the time at which she must have been premeditating the deed, and she stated in it that Fate was pursuing her and she felt that she must die. Another letter, which was addressed to a member of the legal profession, contained explicit instructions as to how her wishes were to be complied with after death, and it also conveyed pathetic farewell messages to some of her friends. The deceased young lady was last seen alive at about 5 o'clock on Saturday evening, when a Mrs Robinson saw her in Mr Miller's grocery shop in George street. Mrs Robinson did not, however, speak to her. Miss White was about 28 years of age at the time of her death, and Dr Colquhoun is of opinion that her letter to him clearly indicated that she was not in her right mind when she wrote it. Deceased had a brilliant educational career. At 13 years of age she won a scholarship at a small school at Circle Hill, near Tokomairiro. She then attended the Dunedin High School, and after being there for two years won a senior scholarship. She subsequently obtained a university scholarship, and in the course of time got her M.A. degree with honours. Her university career being concluded, she devoted herself to teaching and coaching, and her services were much sought after. She was, in fact, overworked — the tuition she gave occupied her day and night, and she denied herself even the usual teacher's holiday on Saturday — and she suffered lately from insomnia. She was latterly in the habit of cycling for the sake of the tonic which the exercise gave her, but it is evident the pressure of work ultimately affected her brain. She was possessed of considerable scholastic gifts and of high literary abilities, and in various contributions she made to the press of this colony she showed a bright and inventive genius Her parents are both dead, but she had four sisters, two of whom she supported by her efforts.  -Otago Witness, 24/6/1897.


Deaths.

White. — At George street, on Saturday, 19th. inst, Marion S. W. White: aged 27 years. — The FUNERAL will leave her late residence at 2.30 p.m. on WEDNESDAY, 23rd inst., for the Southern Cemetery. Friends will kindly accept this notice.  -Evening Star, 22/6/1897.


MISS WHITE'S DEATH.

The sad tidings of the death of Miss Marion S. W. White, M.A., as detailed in our columns on Tuesday, were the topic of much conversation during the day, and general regret was expressed at the demise of a woman of such great talents as Miss White undoubtedly possessed. 

On Tuesday morning Mr Carew, district coroner, held an inquest into the circumstances surrounding the death. Mr A. H. Shelton was foreman of the jury. Mr C. M. Mouat watched the proceedings on behalf of the relatives, and Sergeant Gilbert on behalf of the police. 

Mrs F. H. Campbell deposed that she last saw Miss White alive about 1.30 on Saturday, at the corner of King and Albany streets. They conversed for about 10 minutes. Miss White looked unusually bright and very well, and was cheerful. 

By Mr Mouat: A few weeks ago, on more than one occasion, she complained about her head, and said she did not sleep well. Witness did not know that she took laudanum. 

Charles A. Statham, clerk, residing at Mornington, said he knew the deceased. She was assisting him in his studies. His days were Mondays and Thursdays, but Miss White frequently gave him extra lessons, as she did other pupils. On Saturday morning he got a note from her, delivered by hand, to this effect: "Saturday. My dear Mr Statham, — If you can spare a moment, would you mind calling at my place this evening about half-past 7?" In consequence of this, he went to the house about half-past 7 on Saturday. On the door he found a note, tied by the corner to the knocker, addressed to himself, and asking him "to beg Mrs Wilkie to come to me quickly and to bring a doctor." The note was in Miss White's handwriting. Witness knocked twice, and then, noticing the note, he struck a match and found it was addressed to him or to Mr Ernest Guthrie. Witness took the note to the nearest street lamp and read it, and then made inquiries for Mrs Wilkie. He concluded that the lady named would be Mrs Wilkie in Stuart street, and went to her. Mrs Wilkie read the note. She asked witness to get Dr Macpherson, and then went to the house with witness. Mrs Wilkie's son also came. The key was found under the door mat, and Mrs Wilkie and her son entered the house, witness waiting outside for the doctor. The doctor soon came. 

By Mr Mouat: The deceased often looked overworked, but never complained to him of pains in the head. She was most liberal in her lessons, giving to pupils double what they were entitled to. Witness always thought Miss White was very jovial. She was looking forward to the illuminations, and on Friday asked him if he would join a party she was getting up for Tuesday. 

Eliza Macgregor Wilkie, residing in Stuart street, said she knew the deceased; they were on intimate terms. Witness last saw her alive about two months ago. The parents of the deceased were dead. On Saturday evening Mr Statham showed her a note, in consequence of which she went to deceased's house. She found the key under the door mat. The door was opened, and witness went upstairs to one of the rooms, where she found the deceased lying on a bed in her nightdress, a sheet partly covering her. Witness thought she was breathing. Within five minutes after that the doctor arrived. In the meantime witness had been chafing the deceased's hands. When witness received the note she could not understand why she had been sent for. Deceased had never spoken to her of insomnia, but very often she complained of her head. At the side of the bed there was a chair, on which were placed a small looking-glass, a wineglass, and a handkerchief. Witness did not see a bottle. Witness smelt the wineglass, and detected a smell of spirits — whisky, she thought. There was no smell of almonds. 

Dr Macpherson said he knew the deceased slightly. He was called to her house on Saturday evening, and arrived about 8 o'clock. In one of the rooms upstairs he saw the deceased in bed. Mrs Wilkie said she was afraid Miss White was dying. Witness examined the body and used the stethoscope, and came to the conclusion that she had been dead about an hour. The face and hands were cold, but there was no rigor mortis. The face was extremely pale. There was no lividity, and there was no froth or mucus at the mouth, and no smell to indicate poison. There was nothing outwardly to show the cause of death. Witness examined the room, and the only thing he found to indicate that deceased had probably taken something was a wineglass, which stood on a chair within reach of her hand. It contained about 40 drops of a colourless liquid, which had an alcoholic odour. At the bottom of the liquid were some silky-looking crystals. Witness secured this, and sent for the police. He then examined the downstairs part of the house. He found several bottles of poison — some of them strong mineral acids — and a strong solution of ammonia. The deceased, however, had not been poisoned by any of these; they would leave unmistakable signs at the mouth, and death would have taken place slowly. Besides, there would have been other indications. On Sunday witness applied tests for prussic acid to part of the contents of the wineglass, but no trace of that acid was found. Witness could not say there was poison in the glass. There was nothing in the room from which the deceased could have drunk anything except this wineglass. Witness's opinion was that the glass had contained some powerful poison, probably an alkaloid, and it was likely that a spirit had been added to dissolve it. Medically, in the absence of surrounding circumstances, he could not say the cause of death. 

By Sergeant Gilbert: Witness had been told that deceased had bought prussic acid on Saturday, and that an empty prussic acid bottle had been found outside containing a few drops. If the deceased had taken the prussic acid downstairs and thrown the bottle out she could not possibly have got upstairs. If prussic acid had been taken its odour would have been noticeable in the room or at the mouth for fully 12 hours afterwards.

Ernest White, manager for Mrs Elder, chemist and druggist, said he had known the deceased for several years. She had students in chemistry. She had occasionally bought mineral acids, ammonia, and preparations for chemical testing from witness. On Saturday she came to the shop about half-past 11, and purchased two 2oz bottles of ammonia and nitric acid, which she took away with her, at the same time asking for an ounce of prussic acid. Witness said he could not supply the prussic acid, as it was a dangerous poison. Miss White replied that she understood its properties, and that she used it in chemical tests for her students. Witness said that if she wished to get the prussic acid she would have to obtain an order for it from a justice of the peace. Miss White then said she had such an order from Mr Pryde, and produced it. Witness then supplied her with the prussic acid in the 1oz bottle produced. She was quite cheerful at the time, and spoke of the coming holidays, expressing a hope that the weather would be fine. 

P. G. Pryde, J.P., secretary of the Otago Education Board, said that Miss White called at his office on Saturday, 12th inst., and asked for an order to obtain prussic acid. Witness asked her what she intended to do with it, and she replied she wished it in connection with some experiments in chemistry for her students. She also said she went to witness because he knew her, he knew the work she was doing, he knew the use to which the acid was to be applied, and he was a justice of the peace. Witness then gave the order, being satisfied that the acid was required for experiments. Miss White had been at the office on the 11th to see him, but he was out. He noticed nothing different in her manner when he spoke to her. 

Dr Colquhoun was the next witness. He said: Before I give evidence, Mr Coroner, I would like to state that the use of my name in this morning's report of this case was unauthorised by me and contrary to my wish; the reason being that in my experience, and in the experience of all medical men, publicity given to these cases invariably leads to imitative cases. If I had been consulted as to the use of my name I should have objected, and I desire the representatives of the press to notice that I would like that information conveyed to the editors of the journals. If they publish full details they do so knowing that it almost invariably leads to a multiplication of similar cases. 

The witness then spoke of his knowledge of the deceased. He was acquainted with her professionally, but it would be nine or ten months since he had conversed with her. On Saturday he received a letter from her, dated Saturday. It was written to him from a scientific point of view of her case. It showed, in the first place, that Miss White contemplated suicide at the time she wrote. She said, for instance: "When I feel lightest hearted, a spirit seems to touch me and remind me I have to die." Further on she said she knew the fate was pending for her, and then: "I never thought the act wicked, only inevitable." Further on: "I could do anything with my mind, I fancied, except make the effort to resist the approaching end." Again: "Fear of extinction, I find, is very strong. That I shall not be myself tomorrow is my dread." Further, the letter gave evidence of state of mind which is common in a person with a suicidal mania, and he had no doubt at all she was suffering from that, judging from the intrinsic evidence of the letter. 

By Sergeant Gilbert: There was nothing in the letter to indicate any poison she contemplated taking, but she said in the letter: "At nights, unless I take something to make me sleep, I suffer a good deal." 

By the Coroner: The state of mind disclosed was such as would be induced by over-pressure of brainwork, especially if predisposed to it. 

Frederick Calvert, solicitor, said the deceased was a personal friend of his. He last spoke to her about 10 days ago, but noticed nothing at all wrong with her. She was always jolly. Recently she said to him that she was getting fagged out, and witness advised her to go for a tour on her bicycle, and she said she wished she could. On Saturday night witness was sent for, and Sergeant Gilbert told him the card produced had been found on Miss White's desk, there being written on it: "Send for Mr Calvert, and give him this desk." Witness went to the deceased's residence, and inside the desk he found a letter addressed to himself, also a number of letters addressed to others. The letter to witness was written in a strain that showed the writer penned it knowing he would get it after she was dead. It also gave him instructions as to various of her affairs. There were expressions in the letter which referred to the fact of death being voluntary. From what witness knew of Miss White, he would say she was in comfortable circumstances financially. 

The Coroner produced a note from Professor Black, in which he wrote: "The wineglass handed to me by Constable Daubney contained so very small a trace of liquid — not enough to drop out — that I am not able to identify the constituents except that it is very slightly acid with sulphuric acid. It does not contain prussic acid nor any compound containing strychnine. I have not enough material to test for morphia in a satisfactory way. There is a faint indication of morphia, but not enough to amount to a certainty. I have used up all my material without any satisfactory certain result.

The Jury, after a few minutes' consultation, returned a verdict to the effect that deceased committed suicide by taking poison while in an unsound state of mind, and in answer to the coroner they added that they did not ask for a post mortem examination.  -Otago Witness, 24/6/1897.


THIS MORTAL COIL.

Marion White, M.A., of Dunedin, has committed suicide at the age of twenty-eight! How sad such an end is to a life which, at one time, seemed full of promise, only those who knew her can feel. I was one of those, and when she was quite a girl, noticed the quaint originality and pathos of her work. She and I were co-editors of the Otago Girls' High School Magazine, and like some other editors, when "copy" was scarce, used to fill up blank spaces with our own compositions. We printed the first two issues by means of a gelatine-covered tin plate and purple ink, I can't recollect the name of the machine now, but we used to emerge from our little den about nine o'clock with any quantity of ink about us. It was she who hit upon the idea of encouraging the girls to ask questions in our magazine by making up a good many and answering them herself. Much of her writing in those old times was wonderfully clever, and she possessed that keen sense of humour men say is so rare with women.

It seems hard — when originality is almost an unknown quality among our New Zealand writers — that one who undoubtedly possessed it should after a hard struggle against "the arrows of outrageous fortune," give up the fight and write "Failed" against her life. For others, too, she struggled rather than for herself, I should like in my next letter to quote something she wrote in those old school days, when to me, her talent seemed to promise a brilliant career, and in the "glorious lexicon of youth" there seemed "no such word as fail!" Forrest Ross.  -Wairarapa Daily Times, 24/6/1897.


Marion's suicide was, and is, a tragedy.  I am the first to confess the absence of any ability to discern whether her growing literary talent meant a future place in the history of NZ writing, and how much potential was lost in her death.

I also confess my lack of ability to completely understand what led to her taking her life  but here, for what it is worth, is my guess.

The letter she wrote to Dr Colquhoun, if it still exists  if it were available  would be the key.  Marion was, among her many accomplishments, a student of the human mind and it seems she was attempting to analyse herself for the doctor's information.  One phrase from the small amount published at the time is telling  the idea that "Fate was pursuing her."  This can be interpreted in a number of ways, of course. My guess from the distance of time and understanding is that she felt fated to metaphorically knock on one door after another and to find them always closed to her.

Marion's story after graduation seems to me to be one of trying all she could to develop and use her talents to take her place in the literary and intellectual life of her city and country.  The advertisements and reviews of her lectures and literature classes fail to reveal what may have been the most important aspect of them  did they pay?

Marion was undoubtedly making a living using her intellect and academic credentials.  She was a "crammer"  preparing students for examinations for entrance to university or the civil service.  Possibly, a seemingly endless succession of academic dullards to be trained up just enough for a passing mark.  Marion Steven Wilson White may, at only 27 years of age, have seen her future as the endless wasting of her talents on her paying customers, with the occasional published piece of short fiction only an interlude  certainly not paid enough for her to concentrate on creative writing alone.  And she was intelligent enough to know that her gender was central to her fate and that things were not about to change in the near future, for all that she was able to vote  but not stand for  the government of her country.

The following opinion shows part of what she was up against:


Echoes of the week

The much-to-be-lamented suicide of Miss Marion White, of Dunedin, is a somewhat mysterious affair, but on the face of it the sad event appears to be largely due to the effects of over-study and excess of brain worry upon a naturally high-strung temperament. Higher education is a very good thing in its way, but it is a physiological problem, of great interest to all who study the physical and mental welfare of our New Zealand young women, whether it is not the exception rather than the rule that the striving for and gaining of high academical honours by women is not calculated to work more evil than good. Here, in Miss White’s case we have an instance of bitter disappointment working upon an already overtaxed brain and an ultra sensitive temperament, and driving the poor sufferer on to self-destruction. In older and more populous countries, like England, where there are more channels open, more opportunities at hand for the remunerative employment of the highly educated woman, Miss White might probably have been able to find fairly paid employment suitable to a woman of her exceptional attainments, but even at Home it is a matter of notoriety that the Newnham and Girton graduates, even when provided with private incomes, find it very difficult to put their hardly earned degrees to profitable use. In Miss White’s case, so the telegrams state, “it is known that for some years she has had a bare struggle tor existence!” Far be it from me to underrate the value of higher education, but it may seriously and reasonably be questioned whether, in many cases, the attainment of the ardently desired degree does not mean for our young women a permanent disappointment, added to, in evil effect, in not a few cases, by the injurious after effects of over mental strain upon a weak physique.  -NZ Times, 26/6/1897.


Local and general

Writing to the suicide at Dunedin of Miss Marion White, M. A., the Wellington Post says: — "In this sad death of Miss Marion S. W. White, the growing literature of New Zealand has received one of its severest blows. The deceased lady was one who had educated herself till she obtained her M. A. degree at the Otago University, with honors in English and mental science. She was known as one of the very cleverest of all the women graduates of that University, and she was distinguished by a conspicuous originality of thought. After finishing her course, no other opening being available for her fine talent, she took up the profession of a "coach," with great success. From time to time she contributed to various journals sketches of colonial life that for their insight and unconventionality have not been equalled by any other nativeborn writer. One of these we reprinted from the Otago University Review, and the story, with its hopeless pathos, attracted the widest attention. Its melancholy tone, however, was not her usual style, as most of her stories and articles were distinguished by flashes of the keenest wit and broad touches of humour. It is believed that she was engaged upon a novel of New Zealand life, but it is not known whether that was abandoned before she cut short a life which she regarded as a failure. That so critical and highly original a mind should regard as useless a life so full of promise, is the saddest commentary on her death.  -Wanganui Chronicle, 10/7/1897.


Southern Cemetery, Dunedin.  DCC photo.

Sunday, 9 May 2021

Joseph Ernest Sargent, 1864-16/3/1906

The finding of "temporary insanity" in inquests on suicides was traditionally and historically use to overcome the tradition that people who had committed "self murder" cold not be buried on consecrated ground.  

That tradition had mostly faded by 1906 but the verdict was still a common one.  In the case of Joseph Sargent, it is my opinion that the deduction was factually correct.


EXTRAORDINARY SUICIDE.

STRANGE CONFLICT OF TESTIMONY.

Just after the Otago Daily Times had gone to press yesterday a small party of anxious people went into Messrs Thomson, Bridger, and Co.'s shop, and there discovered the dead body of Joseph Ernest Sargent, who had been employed by the company as bookkeeper. The body lay on the floor of the office, against the telephone, the head in a pool of blood, a bullet-track from the right temple piercing the brain. A revolver loaded in two chambers, with one cartridge fired, lay on the floor by his side. Sargent had been trusted by the firm, in whose employ he held a responsible position. He was quiet and unobtrusive in his manner, notably steady in his habits. He was 42 years of age, and leaves a widow and three young children.

THE INQUEST. An inquest was held yesterday afternoon before Mr C. C. Graham, the coroner, and a jury of six, of whom Mr John McConnell was chairman. Station-sergeant King conducted the proceedings for the police. 

Frederick Williams was first called and sworn: I am a retired newsagent, I reside at the house of the deceased, at 19 Cargill street. Deceased, whose body I identify, was my nephew. He was employed as bookkeeper by Messrs Thomson, Bridgcr, and Co. He was a married man. I last saw him alive at about 8 o'clock last night — the 15th. He was in middling spirits, but in his usual condition so far as I know. He was not in good health. He suffered from nervousness — nothing more than that that I am aware of. He was in low spirits, and had been for some time - many months. The only thing I know of that could account for his depressed state is that he had been overworked at the office. He worked too many hours. It is difficult to say exactly what his hours were. He was there generally from 9 in the morning till 11 or 12 at night; sometimes on Saturday afternoons, and sometimes, I am sorry to say, on Sundays. He was constantly employed such hours as those. I think that undoubtedly it was overwork that was worrying him. I have complained to him myself, and told him he was foolish to keep on working in that manner. He said: "Well, the work was there, and it had to be done." He had no monetary troubles, and no domestic or other troubles. Last night he did not return home as usual. My daughter, who is his wife, and myself went to seek him early this morning. We went to Thomson, Bridger's office. We started for the office about 3 a.m. We found the iron gates unfastened, but the door locked. I knocked loudly, but got no answer. We could see a slight light inside at a distance. We presumed he was there. I got a constable, who said the only way to get in would be to get a key. We got Mr Melton to come down with his key. In company with him and the constable we opened the door, and found deceased lying quite dead in a pool of blood near Mr Melton's office. He was lying very calmly on his back, with his right hand on his chest. A revolver was lying on the floor near him. He never threatened suicide to me. I did not know that he had a revolver in his possession. 

Dr William Evans, duly qualified medical practitioner: This morning, about five minutes to 4, I was called, and proceeded to Thomson, Bridger's premises, where I found the deceased lying on his back. The head was lying in a pool of blood. The right arm was across the chest. His left hand was in his trouser pocket. On the right temple there was a circular wound, roughly about a quarter of an inch in diameter. At the bottom of this wound there was a corresponding hole through the skull. In the left temple the scalp was torn for about an inch and a-quarter, and there was a corresponding hole in the skull. I probed both wounds. Both holes perforated the brain. I concluded that the wound in the right temple was the place where the bullet entered — injuries being evidently inflicted by a bullet, fired at very close range. The edges of the wound on the right side were blackened by powder. The temporal artery on the left side was severed, which accounted for the severe haemorrhage. Death was caused by the shock, and haemorrhage following. The wound could have been self-inflicted. I never attended deceased, and only knew him casually. I can say nothing as to the state of his mind or health. I examined the revolver. It was five-chambered and held two cartridges, one of which had been discharged. Rigor mortis was well marked, and deceased had evidently been dead some hours.

Dr Robert Valpy Fulton: Deceased called on me about six weeks ago to consult me about his health. I found him a physical wreck. His nervous system was shattered. He was evidently worrying very much about trifles — seemed in a constant state of worry about trifling matters. There was evidence of organic disease of the nervous system having set in. He was in a condition bordering on insanity, and I told him that he needed at least three months' absolute rest, and change of scene, and advised him to apply for three months' leave of absence right away. He seemed to think his work was very hard, and seemed to be unnecesarily worried about his work. I understood that he did a great deal of night work. I took no special note beyond that the man was over-working and overworrying. He did not seem inclined to follow my suggestion as to his stopping work. Seeing that he did not apply for leave, I am not the least astonished that he has shot himself. It is just what I should expect. I don't know that he has not applied for leave. 

Adela Kate Sargent: I was the wife of the deceased. I resided with him and my father at 19 Cargill street. My husband had been in a very bad nervous condition since August. His nerves were shattered. I did not know that there was any organic disease. Dr Macpherson saw him last August, before he consulted Dr Fulton. Dr Macpherson said it was nervous prostration, and he must take a rest. My husband thought, he would get better without that. He did not give up work. He got no better. He thought that if he took a holiday be would "get the sack." He did not apply for leave. He had no domestic or monetary troubles, but he fancied that if he lost, his place at Thomson, Bridger's he would never get another. He lost most of his savings in gold-dredging a few years back. I corroborate the evidence given by my father. My husband has taken it into his head lately that I should he better off without him. He fancied that if he was gone my father would look after me. The three children worried him a great deal, they were rather delicate, and he worried over it. Lately he said that he had made some mistake in his work, and he said that Thomson, Bridger might take some proceedings against him, and he would land either in goal or in the lunatic asylum. He had a good deal of night work, but lately I don't think he would have needed to do it if he had been in good health. He could not get through his work in time. We have always lived on the most affectionate terms. Indeed, I think that if he had not cared so much for me he might, have been alive now. He has alwavs done a good deal of night work, but lately particularly so.

William Henry Melton, salesman with Thomson. Bridger and Co., who said he could add nothing to what has been said by other witnesses. I knew the deceased. He was bookkeeper to the firm. I have heard the evidence of Mr Williams. I confirm it, except in some particulars. Mr Williams says deceased worked from nine in the morning till twelve at night, that, is hardly correct. Several nights I have been there and he has not been at the shop at all. In the morning he used to come about nine. He would leave about, halfpast five or six o'clock. He would not come back till half-past nine or ten o'clock. Sometimes he would only come in, put down his books, and go out again. Deceased did not work back every night. I can't say whether he ever applied for leave. He would apply to Mr Thomson direct.

By Mrs Sargent: The hours worked are not entered in any book. No record of time is kept. 

By Sergeant King: The revolver found with the body is one of a make we import. It was a new one, but I cannot identify it as taken from our stock. I have not yet looked at the stock to see.

By Mr J. C. Thomson: Every 'Frisco mail we go back altogether three or four evenings to make up the indent. I should know whether anyone was upstairs working or not. I have seen deceased come in occasionally as we were locking up. He had a key, and could admit himself to the shop.

James Cox Thomson: I am the managing director of Thomson, Bridger and Co., Ltd. I knew the deceased; he was our book-keeper. He was getting £4 10s a week.

Mrs Sargent: £4 10s? 

The witness: Yes, £4 10s, and the office hours were from 9 to 5.30, with an hour's interval for dinner. With the exception of two or three days at the beginning of the month the staff are never back in the office after hours at all.

The Coroner: The question is: if he had a key, he could go back when he chose. 

The Witness: Yes, I am coming to that. The deceased used to remain after the staff left till 6, and sometimes halfpast 6. There was no necessity for any extra night work. With the exception of hearing that he occasionally came back, I was not aware that he ever came back at all. I come back occasionally myself, and I have very seldom soon him there. He was a most accurate worker, and his work was always up to date. The fact that he states that he has made mistakes in the books is, I think, due to a hallucination. There was nothing in his appearance or manner to indicate that he was unwell. I had  intercourse with him daily over office matters, and I could see no difference in him as late as yesterday. He never spoke to me about his health. Had he asked for a holiday he would have got it at once. I have have always given our staff a holiday whenever they have asked for it. We have no rule about holidays, but that is the custom.

By the Foreman: He had had no idea, that any of the firm's employees went back to work on Sundays nor on Saturday afternoons. When he had passed on Saturday afternoons the shop had always been locked up. He should certainly have stopped such work if he had known of it.

The Coroner said there was no doubt as to the cause and manner of death. Death was self-inflicted. The only question was: What was the deceased's state of mind at the time? After hearing Dr Fulton's evidence he did not think the jury could have any hesitation in coming to the conclusion that this poor fellow was out of his mind when he destroyed himself. That unsound state of mind was plainly due to nervous prostration, and that was possibly due to deceased's feeling worried about overwork. Mr Thomson said deceased was not overworked. The organic nervous disease from which deceased suffered might have caused him to imagine that he was overworked, instead of overwork setting up the nervous condition. The statement deceased made as to the condition of his books - as to the risk he ran of gaol and lunatic asylum — plainly showed that his mind was unhinged. Mr Thomson would certainly know if anything was wrong in the deceased's books, and Mr Thomson said the books were accurately kept. It was for the jury to say what the man's state of mind was, having regard to all the circumstances. 

The jury returned a unanimous verdict that deceased committed suicide while in a state of temporary insanity.  -Otago Daily Times, 17/3/1906.


Southern Cemetery, Dunedin.  DCC photo.



Saturday, 8 May 2021

Aaron Faigan, 27/1/1881-25/11/1910.


The phrase "unnatural act" is a little difficult to pin down as to its precise definition from a  century ago.  It seems with certainty to have referred to homosexual acts between men, either with both parties willing or with one party not so.  It also seems to have referred to sexual acts between humans and animals.  The trying  or, at least, the reporting  of such cases tended to be shrouded in euphemism, possibly to protect the tender minds of the younger family members who might have happened upon the daily newspaper.

The New Zealand "Truth" was happy to observe the proprieties with regard to sexual details.  It was happy to pass on the gory ones.


SENSATIONAL SUICIDE.

SEQUEL TO A SUPPRESSED CASE 

Witness Cuts His Throat. What Was There to Fear? — Faigan Full-up — Sought Solace in Suicide — Wife Relieved Him of Razors — But Aaron Severed His Arteries With a Knife.

In the Supreme Court at Dunedin the other day a Jury disagreed in the case in which one Henry Pollock, a Jewish gentleman who kept a tobacconist's shop in George street, Dunedin, was charged with having attempted to commit an unnatural offence. Publication of the evidence was prohibited, which is unfortunate in view of the subsequent sensational death of one of the witnesses. However, it is perhaps permissible for Truth to say that all the witnesses for the defence were Jews, one of them being Aaron Faigan, a married man of 35 years of age, who carries on a tailor's business in Hanover-street. Ever since the jury disagreed, Faigan showed signs of much nervousness, and on the morning of November 25 he was particularly restless, and talked about parting with his wife. About one o'clock Aaron saw Detective Thomson in Castle-street, and left him with the delusion that the sleuth intended to arrest him. From that time until 1.50 p.m. he was in a state bordering on 

NERVOUS PROSTRATION, and on two occasions his wife took razors from him. Later on be said he desired to go to an outhouse, and asked his wife not to follow bim, and she went only as far as the yard, thinking he had no weapon about him. Faigan suddenly slammed the door and his wife rushed in and struggled with him, but could not prevent his cutting his throat with a knife. It was found that Aaron had severed both arteries and must have 

BLED TO DEATH in a very short time. Aaron had been worried over administering the estate of his late father, and a further cause of worry was an anonymous letter recently received, in which a threat to charge Faigan with a certain offence was made, unless money was forthcoming. At the inquest a verdict of suicide whilst temporarily insane was returned.

In her evidence, Mrs Faigan said she struggled hard with her husband, and once had the knife out of his hand, receiving several nasty cuts on her hands and face. She called out for help, but nobody came. Several people came to the fence, but no further — if one of these had helped her, her husband's life could have been saved.  -NZ Truth, 3/12/1910.


A TAILOR’S SUICIDE.

WORRIED TO DEATH. 

Per Press Association. DUNEDIN, Nov. 25. Aaron Faigan, about 35 years of age, carrying on business as a tailor in Hanover Street, committed suicide by cutting his throat. 

Mrs. Faigan states that her husband had been worrying for the last week over being called as a witness in the prosecution against Pollock on a charge of attempting to commit an unnatural offence. All this morning he was in a very nervous state, ana talking of parting with his wife. At one o'clock Faigan saw Detective Thomson in Castle Street, and appeared to think the officer was going to arrest him for some offence.

From that time until 1.50 p.m. he appeared to be in a state of nervous collapse, and his wife took razors from him twice. Faigan then said he must go to an outhouse, and he asked his wife not to follow him. She went only na far as the back yard, thinking he had nothing with him with which he could injure himself. Deceased stood with his back to the door for a while, and then suddenly turned round and slammed the door. Mrs. Faigan hurried to him, and a struggle ensued, but she was unable to prevent him from cutting his throat with a knife. Mrs. Faigan also stated that the deceased had been worried over the receipt of an anonymous letter demanding money under a threat of charging him with a serious offence. He had been further worried over administering the estate of his father, of which he was one of the trustees.  -Taranaki Herald, 26/11/1910.


DEATH OF AARON FAIGAN

A DASTARDLY ANONYMOUS LETTER.

An inquest touching the death of Aaron Faigan, tailor, of Hanover street, was held before the coroner, Mr J. C. Graham, on Saturday morning. Station-sergeant King represented the police, and Mr J. Wilkinson appeared on behalf of deceased's relatives.

The first witness called was Elizabeth Faigan, wife of deceased. She deposed that her husband had been much worried over the case of Rex. v. Pollock, lately before the public, and also by the receipt of an anonymous letter wanting him to send money through the post to a name he did not know. It was an attempt to blackmail by the threat of an accusation against his moral character. He had also been much worried lately over the administration of his father's estate. On Friday morning he did not seem to be himself at all, and witness said she would send for a doctor. She told him he was losing his senses. He wanted her to leave him alone in the morning room, but she discovered a razor in his coat pocket, which she took from him. He got another razor from the bedroom, and that too she took away. His brother came and advised him to sit down, as he was very restless and excited. He said he was going out, and witness said she would go with him, as she was determined not to let him out of her sight. He said, "Don't follow me; you make it all the harder for me." Those were his last words. She told her sister to go for the doctor as she could not watch him any longer. He went to an outhouse, and when he banged the door she ran to him and saw through the ventilator that he was pulling off his collar and tie. She rushed in, seized hold of him, and took from him a large pen knife which he had in his hand, but he got it back. She continued struggling, and received cuts on the hand and face. She called out for assistance, but nobody came. Some stood at the fence, and if they had come in she could have saved the deceased. She struggled with him until he fell down. When Dr Butement came he could only pronounce life extinct. Deceased left two children.

In reply to Mr Wilkinson, witness said her husband had high ideas of the honour of the family name, and could not stand disgrace. He was nervous and highly strung, and very hard working. 

Joseph Faigan, brother of the deceased, corroborated the statements of the last witness as to the condition of his brother the previous day. He had been in a very excited state for the last two or three weeks over thoe case of Rex v. Pollock. Witness knew of the anonymous letter, but deceased did not tell him what he intended doing in connection with it. His brother was dead before he arrived at the house.

To Mr Wilkinson: Although deceased was excited witness never anticipated that he would put an end to himself. 

Constable Sivyer also gave evidence. Dr Butment informed witness that the deceased had severed both carotid arteries, and must have bled to death in a very short time.

The Coroner said there was no need to hear further evidence, and there could be only one verdict. The cause of death was suicide by cutting the throat during a state of temporary insanity.  -Otago Daily Times, 28/11/1910.


Rex v Pollock, in respect to the "unnatural act" charge, ended in acquittal.  The verdict, had Aaron Faigan survived to give evidence, might have been a different one.


Southern Cemetery, Dunedin. DCC photo.


Thursday, 6 May 2021

Hugh Stewart, 1890-13/5/1914.

UNREQUITED LOVE.

A TRAGIC SUICIDE. 

Press Association. DUNEDIN, May 13. "It is better to have loved and lost than never to have loved at all." Hugh Stewart, a young Scotchman, who shot himself dead this morning at the Prince of Wales Hotel, wrote the above quotation on the back of a novel, and added these words: "Written by me in full control of my mind." The man was found dead in a chair in his bedroom about 8 a.m. He was shot through the head, and on the floor lay a revolver with one chamber empty. The circumstances showed that suicide had been premeditated. Stewart arrived in New Zealand from Scotland a year ago and had been employed as a barman. It is stated that the deceased was fond of a girl at another hotel, but that his love was unrequited. Deceased left another quotation: "I have been weighed in the balance and found wanting."  -Sun, 13/5/1914.



The Coroner (Mr O. C. Graham) remarked at the conclusion of the evidence at the inquest on Hugh Stewart yesterday that no doubt the young lady who had refused to marry Stewart had, in the religious circumstances, taken a proper view of the matter. On the outside of the envelope containing a letter addressed “to the general public” deceased had written a request that a gold cross, which would be found round his neck, should be buried with him. The Coroner gave authority for this to be done, and also for the three unopened letters to be forwarded to their respective addresses. The contents of the letter addressed to the public was as follows; — “I am not insane. I have found that I am no longer necessary in this world, so I decided to get out. I want no blame attached to anyone. Please notify my people in Scotland, and if there is anything left let them have it all but letters and silk. Good-bye to everyone. I will pray to meet my father. May God have mercy on my soul, and forgive me for what I have done. — (Signed) ‘Hughie,’ 4th May, 1914.”  -Evening Star, 14/5/1914.


LOVE-SICK SWAIN'S SUICIDE.

Dunedin, May 13. At the inquest on the body of Hugh Stewart; found dead in the Prince of Wales Hotel this morning, the evidence showed that deceased appeared to be in good spirits yesterday. He bought a revolver at a pawn shop, and informed a friend he wanted it “for a bit of sport.” Constable Sorrell said he had interviewed the young lady with whom the deceased was supposed to be in love, and she said she had informed Stewart some time ago that she could never marry him, on account of the difference in their religious beliefs. The coroner returned a verdict that deceased died from the effects of a gunshot wound, self-inflicted while in a state of temporary insanity.  -Stratford Evening Post, 14/5/1914.


Southern Cemetery, Dunedin.  DCC photo.


Tuesday, 4 May 2021

Louis Woolf, 1830-15/8/1864.

A most melancholy, but a most premeditated and determined suicide was committed at the Shamrock Hotel yesterday morning. Mr Joseph Woolf, a well known brewer, destroyed his life by taking a large quantity of strychnine. Pecuniary difficulties, and inability again to face friends, promises to whom he had broken, are set forth as the motives to suicide; for this is the burthen of a letter which the deceased left in the bedroom, addressed to a relative, and there is a repetition of the same statements in writing in his diary, which he did after taking the poison. The case is altogether a most painful one; but we need not here refer further to they circumstances, as a full report of the evidence given at the inquest, will be found in another part of the Times. Mr Woolf was 34 or 35 years old. He was a widower, and he has left two children, a boy and a girl.  -Otago Daily Times, 16/8/1864.


ANOTHER CASE OF SUICIDE.

A very melancholy case of suicide occurred yesterday morning. Mr Joseph Woolf, who was well known as a brewer, destroyed himself bytaking strychnine at the Shamrock Hotel, where he had engaged a bed on Sunday night. As soon as it was discovered what the uphappy man had done, Mr T. M. Hocken, surgeon, and Dr. Hunter were called in. Despite their exertions, Mr Woolf died in about three quarters of aa hour after it was found that he had taken poison. Pecuniary difficulties, as in the recent case of suicide, undoubtedly prompted Mr Woolf to destroy himself, and here, again, those difficulties are described as being slight, and such as might easily have been met and overcome. But Mr Woolf seems to have familiarised himself with the idea of self-murder; and he made an attempt, or avowed his intention to commit the crime, a few months ago. 

Mr Hocken, the coroner, held an inquest on the body, at the Shamrock, during the atternoon, when the following evidence was given. Mr Harvey, solicitor, attended to watch the proceedings on behalf of friends of the deceased, and the Coroner briefly stated the law as applicable fo the case.

William Bulmer Davis: I am a commercial traveller and I reside in the Shamrock Hotel. I knew the deceased for about ten years. I saw him last night, and he told me he was going to sleep here. He was a brewer. I believe that he has two children; his wife is dead. He came to my bedroom about half-past seven this morning. He told me he had been playing cards on Saturday nght and had lost money. He said that his brother-in-law, Mr Joel, had been a great friend to him, and had helped him in every way, and that he was ashamed to face him. He then said, he wanted L28 to make up his accounts to-day, and he asked me to go to Mr Aikman, to see if he would lend it. I said I would if he would give me a letter; and he did, and I went. This is the letter: -

"John Aikman, Will you lend me L20 for one month. I will give you my acceptance for one month as collateral security, until you take the amount out in beer, and I will also allow you a very liberal discount on each hogshead of ale, say l0s. a hogshead. J Woolf. 

"If you will do it give the money to the bearer. Don't mention anything about last night." 

Mr Aikman declined to lend the money. On my return, I found the deceased in my bedroom, where I had left him. He said he would have two hours' sleep. I said, "No, you shall face the matter; and if you are not up when I come from breakfast, I will pull you out of bed." On coming from breakfast, I found him standing against the dressing table, occupied with his books and papers, and he had evidently been writing, for he closed the book as I got to the door. He talked very wildly, which I did not particularly notice, thinking he had been drinking last night; but I went and told Mr Murphy, who got up, and asked him to look in upon the deceased, who was lying on my bed. I then went to Mr Joel, and left word for him to come and see me immediately. He called on me within a quarter of an hour, and we came down here. The deceased at once commenced talking very wildly. He had in his hand three papers, which I took from him while Mr Joel held his hands. Two were empty, and one contained a powder, which you pronounced to be strychnine; all were marked "Strychnine — poison." There might have been more papers, for they were all crumpled up, but I saw three marked as I have stated. Mr Joel ran for a doctor, and you came. I saw you administer something, and also use the stomach pump. I think he survived for an hour. Dr Hunter came, and I saw a deal of coffee used — pumped into the deceased. Whenever the deceased was embarassed, he was always very excitable — he did not like to face difficulties - indeed, he could not face them, and he shunned everything. I never saw anything like insanity about him until this morning, when I thought he had a fit of delirium tremens, and therefore I went to Mr Joel. He was very much excited when he came to my bedroom first. When I say that he talked wildly, I mean that he said that he was ruined - he couldn't get through it - he could not face his brother-in-law, who had helped him so often — and that it was driving him mad. It all related to his prfsent misfortune. I saw the deceased last night: he was perfectly sober, but somewhat excited. When I came back with Mr Joel, the deceased asked Mr Joel to take care of his children, and he asked me to follow him to his grave. I do not remember anything else that he said.

By Jurors: I have known the deceased to be frequently pushed for money; I believe he was embarrassed now, but not to an extent to make man destroy himself. He was afraid to admit to Mr Joel that he had lost at cards. 

By the Coroner: I handed to Mr Michael Murphy a glass that had powder on its side. 

Daniel Murphy: I am one of the proprietors of the Shamrock Hotel. About half-past ten o'clock last night, the deceased came in and asked me for a bed. I told him I had not a bedroom vacant, but I would make up a bed in one of the parlours. I did not see him again until Mr Davis called me this morning. Mr Davis told me that he was going to the deceased's brother-in-law; and he asked me to go into his bedroom and see the deceased, as there was something curious about his conversation. I went and while there the deceased said, "You ought to kick me out for taking strychnine." He was perfectly sober last night, but he was a little excited — more jolly than he used to be. Mr Joel had gone for a doctor when the deceased spoke of strychnine. 

Maurice Joel: I am a storekeeper in Princes street. The deceased was my brother in-law, and was about 34 or 35 years old. When I came to business, about half-past nine o'clock, I heard the message from Mr Davis, and I went to him at Lange and Thoneman's. He told me the deceased was very excited, and I had better go and see him. We came down here at once. The deceased was lying on the bed. He asked me what I came there for — couldn't I leave him alone. I said, "It's no use going on like that," and I sat down on the bed. I saw paper in his hand, and asked, "What have you got there?" and he said "Nothing." We took these papers from him, and then he said, "Well, it's no good - it's too late; you can't help me now." The moment I saw these papers I ran off to Dr. Hocken who gave me a prescription which I got, and Dr. Hocken was here before I got back. The prescription was an emetic, and it made the deceased sick. The stomach pump was used and coffee was copiously administered. I think the deceased died in about three quarters of an hour after I got the papers. I found a letter in the bedroom. This is it: — 

"August 14th, 1864. "Dear Joel and Kate, — For Almighty sake, for my children's sake, do not blame me too much. Your doctrine, I know, is to face the difficulties I, through my own improvidence, have placed me in. I cannot forgive myself for what I have done. I assure you I intended never to play cards any more; but through sitting down to play for a small amount, and losing, and trying to get it back, I believe I have forfeited your confidence. I have not the face to see you. My poor, darling children, God knows who will take care of them, without you and poor Kate look after them. My God, this rash act will, I am afraid, grieve you very much; but I cannot help it. I have made up my mind what I am going to do. Yes, the thought is horrible, but, nevertheless, I have thought of this death for years and years, and at last I am obliged to realise. I did intend to write a long letter, but I find I cannot. My mind is too much occupied. Dear Joel, good bye. May the blessing of a dying man always attend you. For dear Kate's and for your own kindness towards me I feel grateful. For although I was going to write to father and mother, but I find I can not. Joel, I cannot write any more. The time is coming, and then I shall know the grand secret. I leave off with wishing your family and self happiness, and only trust I may be soon forgotten by you. Good-bye, dear Joel and Kate. Joseph Woolf.

"Aikman and Crawford, I have given them a receipt for Ll0 — all they have had from me this month, but I had Ll0 from him yesterday." 

I know the letter to be in the handwriting of the deceased. I did not notice anything wrong in his manner for the last few days He was apparently quite well when I saw him on Saturday afternoon. I remember about six weeks ago, he threw himself on the bed and would not get up or talk about anything. He was very exitable in temperament. He was in a little pecuniary trouble, but I believe he was solvent and something more. 

By Mr Harvey: I do not think I should have at all objected to lend him L28. I had often helped him, and we had not quarreled at all. 

By the Coroner: I found this book, in which the deceased had written this morning. 

The Coroner said the book was a diary, and that under the heading, "Monday, August; 15th," there was written in pencil: 

"Poison is taken. Mercy for my children, Almighty God. I feel the poison, mercy, mercy, on my children. I feel the poison working. My love to you, Kate. Be very kind to my children — a dying man asks you. Maurice Joel, I can write no more. Write to father. Write: I have no time to write to him. Poison is taking effect. I can feel it coming upon me. "J. Woolf."

"I am lying down on my bed to die. Dear Joel, I must write to you, in my dying moments. I say so. My legs, I feel, are getting stiff. God have mercy on me. I have violated my promise to you. Remember me to mother, father, Esther, Kate. Dear Kate, do not fret yourself. You have done all you three could for me, and so has Joel. I must leave off now. God bless Joel. I am sure he wishes me well.'' 

John Aikman: I keep the Glasgow Arms Hotel. I knew the deceased through business. He came to me last night, between nine and ten o'clock, and seemed very much excited. He said that be had been playing cards from Saturday night until just then, and had lost a deal of money. He said he was afraid to go home to Mr Joel's — was afraid to face him. He said that he would leave the place this morning, but I was not to reveal it to any one. I asked where he was going, or what he meant to do; but he said he would not tell me. I pressed to know where he was going, and he replied, "Oh! you'll see it in the Evening Star; but don't you tell any one." I think he said he lost about L30, but I'm not quite sure. He was perfectly sober; but he was excited — from his loss, as I supposed. He got some envelopes and paper from me, saying he was going to write to his parents. 

Samuel Marks: I am a brewer, and was lately in the employment of the deceased. Three or four months ago, he called me into his room — he was lodging in the Shamrock — and burst out crying. He told me he had lost L400 during the week, and he had no money left to meet his bills. He took a pocket book from his pocket, and took out two papers, labelled "Strychnine." He showed them to me, and said he meant to take them. He showed me several letters written on mourning paper, and said they were to his friends. I remonstrated, and he said it was no use, he was determined. I said he would be a great rogue to desert his children. I asked him for the papers, but he refused, and put them into the book, which he pocketed. I suddenly threw him back, and took the papers by violence; I asked him his difficulties, and he told me what money he wanted that day — l60 for one bill and 130 for another. I said. "You shall have it: that's all over. What's next." He spoke of engagements, and I said. "We'll go through the books." I kept with, him all day, and left him calm at night. Whenever he was in difficulty - the slightest - I consider that he was insane; he had not, then, the ordinary prudence of a boy.

By a Juror: My wife burned the papers that I took from the deceased. He said at the time, "It doesn't matter. I can get plenty more."

The Coroner said that when he was called in, a paper was shown to him which undoubtedly contained strychnine; and the symptoms of poisoning by strychnine were unmistakeably manifested by the deceased. The tetanic convulsions were very strong. The deceased spoke once or twice: he asked him to wait a few minutes. He suspected that the deceased must have taken a very enormous dose of the poison; and he believed that no means could have saved him. The deceased vomited almost immediately after taking the emetic.

A Juror: Is it known where he got the poison?

The Coroner said that it was bought of Mr Bagley. It was a great pity that these violent poisons were so easily obtainable, often it was sold avowedly for poisoning rats; but it was a pity that more care was not taken in its sale. It would be useless to call Mr Bagley; he was not to blame in the matter. 

The Coroner again briefly stated the law. It was for the jury now to say whether the deceased, when he look the poison, was laboring under tempory insanity, or whether, while sane, bh destroyed himself. In the latter case, the deceased had committed a crime that deserved punishment as much as the murdering of another person. 

The jury were left to consult for about a quarter of an hour. When the room was again opened, the Foreman (Mr H. Bastings} said that 14 out of the 15 jurors agreed in the verdict, "That the deceased poisoned himself while laboring under temporary insanity." and they also wished to add this rider — "The Jury desire to express their opinion that steps should be taken as soon as possible, to prevent the indiscriminate sale of poisons which has hitherto existed in the Province." 

The Coroner: I will record your verdict, gentlemen; and I will take care to forward your rider to the proper authorities.   -Otago Daily Times, 16/8/1864.


IN THE INTESTATE ESTATE OF JOSEPH WOOLF. 

ALL claims against the deceased Joseph Woolf, of the Red Lion Brewery, are requested to be left, in duplicate, within seven days, at Maurice Joel's, Princes street, Administrator in the above estate. Dunedin, 23rd August, 1864.   -Otago Daily Times, 26/8/1864.


Louis Woolf's brewery, the Red Lion, was managed by Maurice Joel until his death in 1907.


Southern Cemetery, Dunedin.  DCC photo.