James Murphy, (1834-6/5/1894) "first indication of insanity"

 INQUEST.

An inquiry into the circumstances attending the death of James Murphy, whose body was found on Sunday near high water mark at Anderson's Bay, was held at the Bay View Hotel yesterday before Mr Coroner Carew and and six jurymen, of whom Christopher Marlow was chosen foreman.

George Elson, who resided in Walker street, identified the body shown to the jury as that of James Murphy, an Irishman, who had lived in one of witness's cottages for about 12 months. Witness thought he was a single man, but he did not know whether he had any relatives in the country or not. Deceased was a labourer. He paid his rent on the 20th of April, and witness had not seen him about since. On the 27th ult. witness heard that deceased was missing. He had never made any complaints to witness, but witness heard that he had been to see Dr Martin. When deceased left the house there were plenty of provisions in it. He had not been working for 12 months and seemed to be living on his means. Witness believed him to be aa honest man. He never noticed any change in him lately. 

To Sergeant Brown: On the Saturday week after the deceased was missed witness went to his cottage and found a latter addressed to the inspector of police, which he gave to the police. Deceased may have been in the house on the 24th of April although he was missed on the 23rd. Witness never noticed any signs of insanity in deceased, but about six months ago Detective Henderson told him that the man was mad.

The letter referred to by witness in his evidence appeared to have been dated on the 24th ult., and the writer charged four persons with being responsible for his death and expressed the hope that God might have mercy on their souls.

John Rentoul, assistant to Mr A. M. Loasby, chemist, in Princes street south, deposed that he remembered a man named James Murphy coming twice to the shop on Sunday, the 22nd of April. The first time he asked for ls worth of laudanum. Witness told him he could not supply him unless he had witnesses. He then went away and came back again in the evening with two men, and asked witness if he could give him the laudanum then. Witness replied that he could. He also asked Murphy what he wanted the laudanum for, and was informed by him that he wanted it to make him sleep. Witness supplied him with 1oz of laudanum, and told him not to take more than 15 drops. Murphy and one of the witnesses signed the poison book. Witness did not notice anything peculiar about Murphy. He seemed, perfectly rational and sober.

Hannah Elson, daughter of George Elson, deposed that she collected rents for her father, who had a tenant named James Murphy. The last time Murphy paid rent was three weeks ago last Friday. Witness did not notice anything unusual in his manner when he paid the rent. She saw him again on the following Monday morning, and he seemed all right then. 

John Galbraith, a labourer, residing in Walker street, deposed that he had known the deceased for the last 16 months. Witness came to him about eight or ten weeks ago, and he saw the deceased two or three times a week. He went with deceased to the chemist's for some laudanum. While they were in the shop deceased asked witness for 6d as he had forgotten his purse. Deceased seemed quite sensible. Witness saw him again on the following day and thought he looked better. That was the last time he saw him alive.

To Sergeant Brown: Witness did not know that deceased was hard up. 

To the Foreman: He had not known deceased to drink during the last few weeks. 

Thomas Newell, brickmaker, who lived at Anderson's Bay, stated that on Sunday, at about 1 p.m., be was looking out of his back gate, across Anderson's Bay, when he saw an object lying about 20 yards from high water mark. He went to see what the object was, and found it to be the dead body of a man. He informed Constable Hartnett about the matter, and the constable had the body removed to the Bay View Hotel. 

Dr Martin deposed that the deceased was a patient of his eight or ten months ago. He came to see witness frequently about that time. Witness last saw him about the 23rd of August. He was a hypochondriac; he fancied he had a great many complaints, but they were imaginary. This was often the first indication of insanity. Witness had seen the document produced, which was said to be written by the deceased. If deceased did write it witness should think he was of unsound mind at the time he wrote it. There were no marks on the deceased's body except some slight abrasions on the face, which might have been occasioned in the water after death. The body must have been in the water over a week. Witness could not say whether the body was alive or dead when it went into the water. 

The jury returned a verdict to the effect that the deceased was found dead in the mud at Anderson's Bay, and that there was no evidence to show what was the cause of death.  -Otago Daily Times, 8/5/1894.

Southern Cemetery, Dunedin. DCC photo.

John Richard Baxter, (1812-11/10/1892). "gold chaser and stick maker"

SUICIDE.

John Richard Baxter, aged eighty years, a gold chaser and stick maker, committed suicide this morning by cutting his throat with a razor.  -Evening Star, 11/10/1892

SUICIDE.

An inquest on the body of John Richard Baxter, who was found dead with his throat cut at his residence in Rattray street on Tuesday morning, was held at the Britannia Hotel yesterday before Mr Coroner Carew and a jury of six. Mr Charles Johnson was chosen foreman. 

Mrs Catherine Marshall said that deceased was her father, who was born in Birmingham, and had been in the colony about 30 years. He was a widower for the last three years, and was 80 years of age. He was very hearty for his age. Witness last saw him alive at about 10 o'clock on Monday night. She used to go down to his house every evening to make his bed. He asked her to come and see him on Monday as he was in trouble about his rent. He owed L12 for rent, which appeared to worry him very much. Witness stopped with him all Monday, when he seemed to be very cheery. She now thought that his cheerfulness had been a "blind," as he did not want her to see the state of his mind. Witness never thought that he would do such an act, as he was too good a man. She went to his house on Tuesday morning at 10 o'clock. He had left the verandah door open, as was his custom. She went into the shop and called for him, and getting no answer ran upstairs thinking that he was asleep. She went to his door and said, "Daddy, are you not awake yet," but got no answer. When she went into his room and saw what had happened she ran out and told the servant at the Britannia Hotel. On Monday afternoon her father kept walking up and down, saying that he wished he had a lot of money to leave her. He then seemed to be uneasy in his mind. He never had any trouble about money before. He seemed to be getting over his trouble on Monday night, and witness was very pleased to see that. 

Fanny Mulhern, servant at the Britannia Hotel, stated that she saw deceased on Tuesday morning at about half-past 8. He was getting water at the side of the house, and was fully dressed. He seemed to be shaking his head in a rather peculiar way. She saw him shaking his head the same way on Monday afternoon, and witness thought it was a bit strange. She told Mr Porter about the matter. 

Robert Porter, residing at the Britannia Hotel, stated that on Tuesday morning he went to deceased's room. Deceased was in bed, undressed. His head was resting on a wash basin, which was half full of clotted blood. He was dead, and had a wound on the side of the throat. Witness considered the deceased a very temperate man. 

Dr Teevan said he examined the body, and found a wound on the right hand side of the neck about 6in long and 1in deep. There was blood on the hands, shirt, sheet, and basin. The right hand was partly clenched, and the left hand extended in the ordinary way. All the exposed parts of the body were quite cold, and the parts under the sheets partly warm. On a table near at hand was an open razor, covered with blood. The wound could have been self-inflicted by the razor (produced). There were no signs of any struggle. He thought the body had been dead about two hours. 

Arthur Marshall, grandson of deceased, and Constable McGill also gave evidence. 

A verdict to the effect that deceased cut his throat whilst temporarily insane was returned. 

Mr J. A. Hislop, who appeared for Messrs Speight and Co., the landlords of deceased's house, stated that as reference had been made to deceased having been worried about rent, the inference was that the present landlords, who have owned the premises for the past six weeks or so, were pressing him. Such, however, was not the case, as they had never, since they became landlords, asked him for rent, or even sent in an account. The rent must have been owing to the former landlords.  -Otago Daily Times, 13/10/1892.

Southern Cemetery, Dunedin. DCC photo.

John McBain, (-12/10/1889). "witnessed the celebrated carge"

 

John McBain, a Crimean veteran, aged 63 years, died at Dunedin on Saturday of cancer. He belonged to the Royal Artillery, and took part in the battles of Alma, Balaclava, and Inkerman, and held a medal and four clasps.  -Poverty Bay Herald, 18/10/1889.

A CRIMEAN VETERAN.

There died at Ravensbourne on Saturday morning John McBain, a Crimean veteran, deserving of some passing notice. McBain enlisted at Aberdeen on March 18, 1848, into the Royal Regiment of Artillery; from thence he was forwarded to Woolwich, the headquarters of the regiment. A few years' garrison work at Woolwich and Devonport brought up the interval till 1854, when he was drafted into the Royal Horse, and put under orders for the Crimea, where he arrived September 16, 1854. No time was lost here, for in four days after his arrival he was taking part in the battle of Alma, and about a month later he was in the battle of Balaclava where, with his battalion, he witnessed the celebrated charge of the Light Brigade. On the 5th November he was in the Battle of Inkerman, which McBain always spoke of as being the most stubbornly contested of all the Crimean battles. During the following 10 mouths his detachment did good service in the protracted siege of Sebastopol. For these engagements he bore the Crimean medal with the four clasps, as also the Turkish medal. On the arrival of the troops in England they were inspected by the Queen and Princess Victoria, now Empress Dowager of Germany. At the parade McBain carried on his shoulders an enormous Russian cat which he had brought from the Crimea, and which attracted her Majesty's attention so much that on the same evening the cat had found a royal mistress, and McBain was the happy possessor of a sum of money far exceeding its value. After a short spell of nine weeks at headquarters M'cain went with his regiment to the lonian Islands. From here he was sent back to England as recruiting sergeant and to assist in procuring horses, at this time men and horses being in great demand for the Indian mutiny. On the a-completion of about two years' recruiting work in England he left with his recruits for India, via Corfu, where they picked up the remainder of the regiment, arriving at Point de Galle in 1859. By the time they arrived in India the mutiny was over, and the batteries were distributed among the various subjugated districts to assist in maintaining the peace that hid just been arrived at. During his stay in India, which extended over several years, McBain passed most of his time as officer's servant to a gentleman who was a keen hunter of the wild beasts then swarming in the jungles. His many reminiscences of these stirring scenes were highly entertaining, and the recital to intimate friends of his own share in this work helped to while away many a dreamy hour during the earlier stages of his illness. On the completion of 21 years of service he received his discharge, when he emigrated to Otago, where he has been for the past 17 years — for some time at South Dunedin, and latterly at Ravensbourne. About 10 months ago he was attacked by a virulent form of cancer, causing great pain and discomfort, most heroically borne, and from which he was happily released on Saturday last, at the age of 65.  -Otago Daily Times, 14/10/1889.

Southern Cemetery, Dunedin. DCC photo.

James Pithers, (1839-5/10/1889). "did not know how he got there"

SUICIDE BY SHOOTING.

(BY TELEGRAPH. — PRESS ASSOCIATION.) Dunedin, this day. 

James Pithers, a newspaper runner latterly employed as a gardener, committed suicide at Roslyn by shooting himself with a gun. He had been much depressed in spirits since his return from Sydney, whither he had gone to visit his only relative three months ago. A month ago his mind became slightly unhinged. Deceased was fifty years of age and unmarried.  -Auckland Star, 7/10/1889.

SUICIDE AT ROSLYN.

An inquest was held this morning, at Roslyn, before Mr Coroner Carew, on the body of James Pithers. The following is a summarised report of the proceedings: 

James A. Park, auctioneer, said that the body shown to the jury was that of the late James Pithers. Witness thought he was an Englishman, born in London. He had been upwards of fourteen years in the colony. He had been in witness’s employ for over four years as handyman and gardener. He was not married, so far as witness was aware of. Witness had known him for about two years before employing him. He was working about the district, and previous to that he was a Star runner. His health broke down the winter before last, and he was then under the impression that he would not last through that winter. About four months ago he caught cold and had a severe attack of pleurisy, and, witness thought, visited Dr Brown. After his recovery he was very weak, and spoke of taking a trip to Auckland to see if it would improve him in any way; but instead of Auckland he visited Sydney, having relations there. It was, witness believed, fully a month before he found his relations there, which seemed to make him despondent. He returned to Dunedin on the 31st August last. He said he felt better, but he did not look any better. About a month from Thursday last he got up in the middle of the night and wandered to Port Chalmers. He said when he came back that he did not know how he got there. Witness saw him the following day, and he seemed to be perfectly sane. Mrs Park offered to send for a doctor, but he said he was perfectly right and would not have a doctor to see him. Since then he would very seldom leave the premises, seeming as though he did not want to meet anyone who would talk to him about his past movements. Witness had had a lad at the place recently, and used to ask him about Pithers, whether he noticed anything wrong about him. His answers were always “No,” and to the effect that he was all right and quiet. On Friday night witness beard the servant said he was brighter and more cheery than he had been, but that he spoke strangely sometimes. The last time witness spoke to Pithers was on Thursday morning between 8.30 and 9 o'clock, and got rather a quiet reply. Immediately after replying Pithers walked away. Since then it had occurred to witness as strange that Pithers did not stay to speak to him as he usually did; but that did not occur to witness at the time. Witness fancied that Pithers considered himself a burden and of no use, because he had not been able to do the work he used to do. The lad was only temporarily there to assist him in heavy work. Witness never gave Pithers reason to think he was dissatisfied with him. Witness told him, after he wandered to Port Chalmers, that he was foolish to brood over matters. He said if he had been in business he should have gone wrong long ago. Witness told him that so long as he liked there was a home for him with witness, and that he could potter about and do what he could. Witness thought he was over fifty years of age, but he made himself out, witness believed, to be forty-eight years. He had wandered about a good deal during his life — had been in Victoria, through part of the Maori War, on the Otago diggings, and at Allans’ of Hopehill, before he came to town. The carbine produced was witness's property. It used to be in Pither’s custody. Whenever witness gave it up to him it was always empty. On Saturday morning witness asked Pithers to have his rifle cleaned and have it ready by the afternoon, which witness understood he did. Witness heard at lunch time what had happened to Pithers.

Dr Brown said that on Saturday last he was called by telephone; and arrived at Mr Park's at a few minutes before 2 p.m. He found the body lying on its back in an outhouse, at full length on the ground. Deceased had the barrel of a carbine in his right hand, pointing towards his head. The right side of his bead was blown to pieces by the discharge of the carbine. Portions of the skull and brains were lying beside the body, and nieces of brain were scattered about the woodhouse, the roof, and floor. The injuries could have been self-inflicted. In October, 1888, he consulted witness. He was then sutffering from pleurisy. Witness had not seen him since. Any severe illness might depress a man mentally; if it lasted long it would be very likely to do so. 

Margaret Anderson, general servant at Mr Park’s, said that she had asked Pithers what made him dull, but he did not tell her. He said: “Never mind; you don’t know anything about it.” The night before he went to Port Chalmers he said that he was tired of living. He did not say why. He said he would like a good walk. Witness had never since then heard him talk about making away with himself. On Saturday morning he was very quiet and dull, and hardly spoke to witness. It was the same at breakfast and dinner-time. He had his dinner about five minutes past twelve. He did not eat much, and said he wished he had a good appetite. Witness did not see him with a gun that morning. Before he went to Port Chalmers witness sometimes thought his mind was affected, but had not thought so since. The people in the house were always very kind to him. 

Richard Harris said that he knew Pithers, and used to work with him at Mr Park’s at gardening. Witness had noticed that he was very quiet for the past two or three days. After witness returned from dinner on Saturday he found Pithers’s body lying on the floor, and reported the occurrence. 

The jury returned a verdict to the effect that deceased shot himself while temporarily insane.  -Evening Star, 7/10/1889.

The Dunedin Herald of last week says: — The suicide of James Pithers was one of the most revolting that has been seen for many a day. We refer, of course, to the state in which the body was found. The right half of the face was blown completely away, and huge pieces of skull and brain were lying about, some at a distance of about four yards. The body was lying in a little lake of blood, in which pieces of brain and bone were floating. The bullet, after doing its deadly work, cut its way through the wooden ceiling and galvanised iron roof of the shed. The one redeeming feature of the affair was the coolness dismayed by a young man named Richard Harris, who first discovered the deed. When he entered the building he had two of Mr Park's children with him and taking in at a glance the state of affairs, but not wishing to terrify the children, he quite coolly called "Jim," and receiving, of course, no reply remarked "Oh! he's not there, let's go and see where he is," then turned and walked away.  -Poverty Bay Herald, 17/10/1889.

James Pithers lies in an unmarked, pauper's grave in Dunedin's Southern Cemetery.

Arthur Empson, (1852-11/9/1889). "heard voices and telephones"

DETERMINED CASE OF SUICIDE.

A most determined case of suicide occurred at Josephine street, Caversham, on the 11th ult. A man named Arthur Empson, who with his wife had recently come to reside at Darley, Caversham, got out of his bed and went into the kitchen to get some tea for himself, having previously knocked out of his wife's hand a cup which she had brought him. On getting into the kitchen he seized a large bread knife, and proceeded to cut his throat with it. His wife, seeing what he was about, ran outside and called for help to a neighbour, who on going to the door saw Empson with a terrible gash in his throat. He was so horrified at the spectacle that he ran off for assistance, and on his return the man was lying on the floor dead. An inquest was held in the afternoon, and evidence was adduced that the suicide, after inflicting wounds on the throat with the bread knife, then took up another knife with a sawback to it, and so desperate was he that he appears to have used the back part of it, and sawed right through to the back bone. 

Elizabeth Matilda Empson, wife of deceased, deposed that he was born in Yorkshire, England, and had been in New Zealand between 12 and 13 years, but had been away during that time. They had been married six years last March. Deceased had been travelling since last Christmas. They left New Zealand in March last, and came back again about the middle of August. They came to reside in Caversham about three weeks ago. Deceased had a run of his own at Rangitata at one time, and had been manager on a station in the Bothwell district, Tasmania, lately. Deceased had on several occasions been queer in his mind, but had never been in the asylum as a patient. He was sent to the hospital in Albany, Western Australia, suffering from insanity, and was detained there a week. Since coming to Caversham he had been in very good health, but during the last few days witness noticed that he became quiet, walked round and appeared nervous. He followed witness round wherever she went. He imagined he heard voices and telephones. This was the way he always went on when he went wrong in the head. On Tuesday he kept saying there was some one coming for him, but who witness did not know. He told witness that he had gone to town in the morning and posted two letters, and that her brother-in-law had sent the police after him for not drinking. Witness had a brother-in-law in Wanganui, but none in town. Later on he tried to stab himself with the scissors. Witness knew this by the blood on his shirt when they were going to bed about 10 o'clock. Witness asked him how the blood came on the shirt, and took hold of him. He said he did it when he fell against his scissors. These had entered the skin. At 9 o'clock on Wednesday morning witness took him a cup of tea to bed, and he threw the cup out of her hand and said he would get one for himself. He then got up and went into the kitchen, and as he was coming through he pulled off his trousers. On getting into the kitchen, he seized the bread knife and put it up to his throat as if to cut it. Witness did not think he was using the front of the knife till she saw the cut. He kept on sawing, and witness ran out of the house by the back door, and screamed out to her neighbour, Mr Waterstone, who came out at once and went to the door of the house. He then went away for someone. Witness went to the door with Mr Waterstone, and saw deceased with the knife still in his hand. When Mr Waterstone went away witness stayed out by the gate till the butcher and someone else came. They went inside, and witness saw the feet of deceased who was lying on the floor. Previous to this deceased had been standing up. He never spoke. Witness again Baw her husband when the constable came, and he was then dead. He had spoken about making an attempt on his life before, but had never tried to carry it into effect. He had said in Western Australia that he would cut witness' throat first and his own afterwards. He never gave any reason for saying this. Witness put the scissors, deceased's razor, and knives away on Tuesday night when she had found that he had tried to harm himself. Witness knew that there was insanity in the family. His cousin shot himself, and the mother and sister died not altogether sane. Witness was not aware that deceased had had anything to worry him of late. He was not in the habit of drinking to excess, but took a glass of liquor occasionally. Witness always considered that she was perfectly safe in living with deceased, and thought that she could manage him by means of persuasion. He very rarely spoke to anyone in Caversham, but would occasionally speak to things in the room and imaginary persons. Witness said to him that she would send for a policeman the next morning, when she saw the blood on his shirt on the Tuesday night. He said it would soon be over, but witness did not know what was meant by that. She did not think it necessary to place him under restraint of any kind. Witness had been using a bread knife in the kitchen before he came in. She never expected him to get out of bed and did not want him to do so, as he might rush down the street or do some such foolish thing. Witness did not think it was necessary to send for the police overnight, as she had seen deceased quite as bad before. He talked all night. By medical advice given on a previous occasion, witness was told to hide all knives away. The other knife produced was not a bread knife, but belonged to a set of kitchen utensils. It was hanging up in a frame, and deceased must have laid the bread knife down and taken the other one out. When first deceased came to Caversham he was fit to attend to business, but had not been so for the past few days. Deceased was 32 years of age.

John Waterstone, Constable Higgins, and Dr Coughtrey also gave evidence, and

The jury returned a verdict that deceased killed himself by cutting his throat while of unsound mind.  -Otago Daily Times, 2/10/1889.

Southern Cemetery, Dunedin. DCC photo.

George Ward, (1865-7/1/1889). "he had spent it all"

DEATH BY HANGING.

George Ward, about twenty-seven or twenty-eight years of age, supposed to belong to the Oamaru district, was found dead this morning, suspended by a rope made fast to a beam in a stable at the rear of Mr Reany’s Globe Hotel, Princes street south. Deceased had been boarding in the house for about four weeks past, and late on Saturday evening went out apparently for a walk. Since then he was not seen by anyone about the hotel until 9.15 this morning, when Archibald McArthur, who has been staying at the Globe for a day or two past, went into the stable for something, and found Ward hanging by the neck. McArthur at once called the landlord, who cut the body down and sent for the police. Dr W. Brown was also summoned, but an examination revealed the fact that the man had been dead for some time, the corpse being stiff and cold. No money was found on Ward’s person, but there were portions of a letter from his brother, who resides at Brookfield, Oamaru, from which it is gathered that deceased recently received some money from his brother; and this, taken in conjunction with the absence of money on his person, would show that deceased had been hard up. Ward told a person who spoke to him on Saturday afternoon that he had come from the Taieri, where he had been working on a farm. Ward was at that time perfectly sober, and had the appearance of a happy and temperate man. He was certainly not a drunkard. The motive that led to the perpetration of the fatal act may, perhaps, be disclosed at the inquest, which is appointed to be held to-morrow, at 11.30 a.m. The delay is caused by the desire to have his brother at the inquest. Meanwhile it would serve no good purpose to even guess at the cause or causes that prompted the hanging.  -Evening Star, 7/1/1889.

SUICIDE IN A STABLE.

An inquest was held this morning at the Globe Hotel, before Mr Coroner Carew and a Jury of six, of whom D. Henry was chosen foreman, touching the death of George Ward. 

Dr William Brown stated that when called to the hotel yesterday morning he saw the body in the stable. It was quite dead. Death must have occurred some hours previously. It was quite possible that deceased might have been in the stable all night. There was the mark of a rope round his neck. Witness saw the rope produced and also the piece of rope attached to the beam. The mark on the neck indicated that the rope had been put on during life. There was no external indication that death arose from any other cause than hanging. 

Thomas Ward, laborer, residing at Brookfields, Oamaru, identified the body as that of his brother, who was born in Shropshire, was twenty-four years of age, and had been in New Zealand nearly two years. Deceased was a laborer and a single man. Witness last saw him alive on the 7th of last March. Letters received from deceased stated that be was doing well in his situation up to the middle of November; but a letter written in December mentioned that he had left his situation and gone to Dunedin, adding that he had met with a misfortune and lost his money, and asking his brother to lend him some money that would keep him until he got into a situation. Witness sent L5, the amount asked for. Eleven or twelve days ago deceased wrote again, stating that he was not well enough to go to a situation, and asked for a similar sum to that sent previously. Witness sent him L4, but got no reply to the letter enclosing it. Deceased was not in any difficulties excepting in regard to the money, so far as witness knew. Witness had never heard of his brother being wrong in his mind, and could form no idea as to his reason for making away with himself. In one of his letters deceased said that he bad lost his money by getting into bad company. 

Archibald McArthur, miner, had been residing at the hotel for eight days, and had known Ward during that time. On Saturday night he was in the best spirits. Witness had never seen him the worse of liquor, and did not suspect that he was ill. On Monday morning witness found deceased hanging in the stable, fully dressed, his feet being four or five inches from the ground. Nothing that Ward ever said to witness gave the least clue to his reason for making away with himself. The body was cold and stiff when cut down. 

Joseph Reany, landlord of the Globe, said that Ward had been living at the hotel for about a month. He was a very steady man, strong-minded, and jolly, and the last person in the world witness would have thought of as likely to commit suicide. 

Harriet Palmer, residing in the hotel as cook until Saturday, last saw deceased alive at 4.5 p.m. on Sunday, at the Dunedin Railway Station. He said he was going to Oamaru to his brother, and if he did not go on the Monday witness was to see him in town. Deceased had threatened to do away with himself. He said so to witness on Saturday, adding that he was tired of his life. He had no money — he had spent it all — and seemed low-spirited, but promised witness that he would not do anything to himself. When Ward said that he would do away with himself witness did not at first think he meant what he said, but he repeated the statement two or three times, and then she began to be frightened that he would do something, though she said nothing to anybody about the matter. He gave witness the letters produced to mind for him. On Saturday night witness and deceased went for a walk out to the Ocean Beach, and he there threatened to make away with himself. He wanted to go into the water, but witness would not let him. She did not leave him that night — they were walking about the whole time — and she kept by him until five minutes past four on Sunday afternoon, when she left for Sawyers Bay. Ward was apparently quite right in his mind. They parted on friendly terms. 

Patrick Dwyer, landlord of the Southern Hotel, said that Ward went into that house about five o’clock on Sunday afternoon to ask witness if they had not met at Oamaru. He remained in the hotel chatting for nearly an hour, and seemed quite sane. He did not ask to be served with drink, and did not look as though he had been drinking. 

Constable Green had spoken to deceased on Saturday afternoon, when he seemed to be comfortable and happy. Among the articles found in his possession was a pawn ticket notifying that he had pledged his swag on the 5th inst. 

The jury returned a verdict that deceased killed himself by hanging, but that there was no evidence to show the state of his mind at the time he committed the act.  -Evening Star, 8/1/1889.

Southern Cemetery, Dunedin. DCC photo.

Ebenezer Hay, (1850-20/4/1887). "some strong delusion"

SUICIDE OF A SOLICITOR.

(By Telegraph.) Dunedin, April 20. 

Mr E. Hay, the solicitor, committed suicide this afternoon by cutting his throat. 

LATFR. The suicide of Ebenezer Hay appears to have been most determined. He was living with his sister, who left him in the house. On returning she found that he had taken a basin to hold the blood and then hacked away at his throat, with a blunt knife, the basin being full of blood. He appears then to have gone to the bathroom, where the bath was found with blood and water mixed. His sister at once procured medical aid, and though when the doctor arrived Hay was pulseless, he tore away at the wound with his nails. He died shortly afterwards. He was a single man and had been indulging rather freely. It is supposed he committed the rash act while suffering under some strong delusion.   -Timaru Herald, 21/4/1887.

Ebenezeer S. Hay, the well-known solicitor, committed suicide yesterday by cutting his throat with a knife. He was a single man, and had published some sonnets which were highly spoken of.  -Lake County Press, 21/4/1887.

SUICIDE OF A BARRISTER.

We are sorry to have to record the death of Mr E. S. Hay, barrister and solicitor, from suicide yesterday afternoon. He had been in very depressed spirits for some time past, and since Tuesday was confined to the house. Hehwent to bed yesterday afternoon, and about half-past three o’clock it was found that he had cut his throat with a table knife. Drs Coughtrey and Stirling were immediately sent for; but, although the deceased was not dead, they were unable to save his life, as he had lost such a quantity of blood. 

THE INQUEST. 

An inquest was held by Mr Coroner Carew at the deceased’s residence, George street, this afternoon at three o’clock. 

David Rennie Hay, tailor, identified the deceased, who was thirty-seven years of age. He had been about twenty-two years in New Zealand. Witness last saw him alive at twenty minutes to twelve o’clock yesterday. He was suffering from want of sleep, and said he was mesmerised. Witness had brought a sleeping-draught for him, but could not persuade him to take it. Witness conversed with the deceased, but he was too exhausted to talk in his usual manner. He gave foolish answers to some of witness’s questions, and witness concluded that he was not compos mentis. Witness had not seen him for some days previously. It was owing to one of his sisters being out of town that the deceased was left by himself in the house. Witness had not the slightest idea that it was unsafe to leave him alone.

Isabella Hay, school-teacher, deposed that the deceased came home on Tuesday morning in rather an excited state. He appeared to have been drinking, and was under several delusions. Yesterday when witness came home from school for lunch she persuaded him to go to bed. She did not like leaving him, but did not think there was the slightest danger in doing so. He was very quiet. Witness went back to school, and returned home about twenty minutes past three. She immediately went to the deceased’s bedroom, and, finding the state he was in, went for Drs Stirling and Coughtrey. 

Dr Robert Stirling gave evidence as to finding the deceased in bed with a wound in his throat. The wind-pipe was severed, but the large blood-vessels were untouched. Witness found the table-knife (produced) in the bedroom. Witness sent to Dr Coughtrey, and they put a silver tube in his throat. The deceased lived for some time, but finally succumbed to hemorrhage. 

The jury returned a verdict that the deceased committed suicide while in a state of temporary insanity.  -Evening Star, 21/4/1887.

Southern Cemetery, Dunedin. DCC photo.